Supreme Court Second Session Final Roll 2021

Court: 
Supreme Court
Date: 
08 July 2021

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF ESWATINI 

 

SECOND SESSION COURT ROLL 2021

 

FINAL

 

TO: Honourable Chief Justice

      Honourable Justices of Appeal

      Honourable Justices of the High Court

      Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court of

      Appeal

      Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court

      Attorney General

      The Director of Public Prosecutions

      The Registrar of the High Court

      The Registrar of the Industrial Court of Appeal

      The Registrar of the Industrial Court

      The National Commissioner of Police

      The Commissioner General of Correctional       Services

      The Law Society

      Litigants in Person

 

 

 

 

 

NOTICE

 

  1. ALL MATTERS WILL BE HEARD IN COURT A AND ATTORNEYS ARE ADVISED TO ATTEND COURT TIMEOUSLY.

 

  1. ATTORNEYS ARE FURTHER ADVISED TO COMPLY STRICTLY WITH THE RULES OF COURT IN RESPECT OF THE RECORDS OF PROCEEDINGS, THE FILING OF HEADS OF ARGUMENT AND THE LIST OF AUTHORITIES

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

__________________________________

REGISTRAR – SUPREME COURT

 

 

 

DATE:      ________________________________

 

 

 

 

 

             

 

 

 

CIVIL AND CRIMINAL CASES

 

MONDAY 19 JULY 2021

 

1.      CIV/APP. 40/2020 – APPEAL

 

          BUYISILE DLAMINI

          AND

          LOTI NICHOLAS DLAMINI & TWO OTHERS

 

T. L. DLAMINI                                         C. J. LITTLER ATTORNEYS

ATTORNEYS

 

TUESDAY 20 JULY 2021

 

2.      CRIM/APP. 62/2017 – APPEAL

 

          CATHERINE HLATSHWAKO

          AND

          REX

 

BEN J. SIMELANE ATTORNEYS                       DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 21 JULY 2021

 

3.      CRIM/APP. 13/2020 – APPEAL

 

          MBONGENI MAZWI MNGOMETULU & ANOTHER

          AND

          REX

 

NZIMA ASSOCIATES                                            DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

MONDAY 02 AUGUST 2021

 

4.      CRIM/APP. 18/2018 - APPEAL

 

          JOHANNES MFANUKHONA DLAMINI & ANOTHER

          AND

          REX

 

LINDA DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 03 AUGUST 2021

 

5.      CIV/APP. 04/2021 – APPEAL

 

      MDUDUZI MABILA

      AND

      SIPHIWO MASUKU

 

LINDA DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES                    MTSHALI       NGCAMPHALALA ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 04 AUGUST 2021

 

6. CIV/APP. 83/2020 - APPEAL

 

      FRANK BARAS & THIRTY-THREE OTHERS

      AND

SWAZILAND TRANSPORT & ALLIED WORKERS UNION AND ANOTHER

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                            MUSA M. SIBANDZE   ATTORNEYS

THURSDAY 05 AUGUST 2021

 

7.      CIV/APP. 64/2020 – APPLICATION

 

          LUCAS M. MAZIYA         

          AND

          REGISTRAR – SUPREME COURT & OTHERS

 

NZIMA AND ASSOCIATES                          WARING ATTORNEYS

 

 

8.      CIV/APP. 67/2019 – APPLICATION

 

          HOME BASE INVESTMENT (PTY) LIMITED & TWO OTHERS

          AND

          FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF ESWATINI

 

 

BOXSHALL – SMITH ASSOCIATES                           MJ MANZINI   

                                                                                                 ASSOCIATES

         

 

 

 

MONDAY 09 AUGUST 2021

 

9.      CIV/APP. 84/2020 – APPLICATION

 

          ESWATINI NATIONAL PROVIDENT FUND BOARD

          AND

          LUCAS M. MAZIYA

 

WARING ATTORNEYS                               NZIMA & ASSOCIATES

 

 

10.    CIV/APP. 23/2020 - APPLICATION

 

          KENNETH VAN ZYL

          AND

          ESWATINI NATIONAL PROVIDENT FUND BOARD

 

IN PERSON                                                        WARING ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 10 AUGUST 2021

 

11.    CIV/APP. 63/2019 - APPLICATION

 

          SOLOMON MTHETHWA

          AND

          SHISELWENI FORESTRY COMPANY LIMITED

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS         MLANGENI &

                                                                                      COMPANY

 

WEDNESDAY 11 AUGUST 2021

 

12.    CIV/APP. 09/2020 – APPEAL

 

          ELLEN NOMSA DLAMINI

          AND

          NONHLANHLA PRINCESS DLAMINI & THREE OTHERS

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                      N. E. GININDZA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 12 AUGUST 2021

 

13.    CIV/APP. 06/2018 – APPEAL

 

          LOWVELD TRUCKING (PTY) LTD

          AND

          SWAZILAND RAILWAY

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                   ROBINSON BERTRAMS

ATTORNEYS

 

MONDAY 16 AUGUST 2021

 

14.    CIV/APP. 90/2020 – APPLICATION

 

          TRIOMF SWAZILAND (PTY) LIMITED

          AND

          DIAMOND CONTRACTORS (PTY) LTD

 

M. L. DLAMINI ATTORNEYS       RODRIGUES & ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 17 AUGUST 2021

 

15.    CIV/APP. 45/2020 – APPLICATION

 

          SAMKETI DLAMINI

          AND

          XI PANDA FOODS (PTY) LIMITED

 

T. L. DLAMINI                             S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES

AND ASSOCIATES

 

 

WEDNESDAY 18 AUGUST 2021

 

16.    CIV/APP. 74/2019 – APPEAL

 

          SILVER FALCON T/A 288 (PTY) LIMITED & ANOTHER

          AND

          KIMULIMULI (PTY) LIMITED

 

GIGI A. REID ATTORNEYS           S. V. MDLADLA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 19 AUGUST 2021

 

17.    CIV/APP. 86/2020 – APPLICATION

 

          SIFISO RONALD MAPHALALA

          AND

          LITTLE INTELLECTUALS DEVELOPMENT CENTRE (PTY)

          LIMITED

 

NZIMA ATTORNEYS                                   WARING ATTORNEYS

 

MONDAY 23 AUGUST 2021

 

18.    CIV/APP. 95/2020 – APPEAL

         

PHUZAMOYA LIMITED

          AND

          BEBESHA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

 

HENWOOD & COMPANY                               ZONKE MAGAGULA

                                                                                  ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 24 AUGUST 2021

 

19.    CIV/APP. 20/2021 – APPEAL

 

          FIDELITY GROUP SERVICES SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

          AND

          BULLDOG DISTRIBUTORS (PTY) LTD

 

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                            NKOMONDZE

ATTORNEYS                                                                       ATTORNEYS

 

 

20.    CIV/APP. 32/2020 – APPLICATION

 

          JABULANI MNDZEBELE

          AND

          NONHLANHLA SHONGWE

 

IN PERSON                                  MUSA NSIBANDZE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 25 AUGUST 2021

 

21.    CIV/APP. 26/2021 – APPEAL

 

          ESPERANZA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LIMITED

          AND

          FLORENCE FALABO BENNET N.O & FOUR OTHERS

 

NKOMONDZE ATTORNEYS                    S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES

                                                            

 

THURSDAY 26 AUGUST 2021

 

22.    CIV/APP. 12/2021 – APPEAL

 

          SIMANGALISO PATRICK MAMBA

          AND

          ACKEL ZWANE & TWO OTHERS

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                         M. S. DLAMINI - LEGAL

ATTORNEYS                

 

 

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 13 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

23.    CIV/APP. 68/2015 – REVIEW

 

          BEAUTY BUILD CONSTRUCTION (PTY) LIMITED

          AND

          MUZI P. SIMELANE T/A MP SIMELANE

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDZE

ATTORNEYS                                                                  ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 14 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

24.    CIV/APP. 01/2021 – APPEAL

 

          ALDONA LAPIDOS

          AND

          ZINHLE MASEKO-MDLULI & TWO OTHERS

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                       C. J. LITTLER  & 

ATTORNEYS                                                              COMPANY

 

 

WEDNESDAY 15 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

25.    CIV/APP. 78/2020 – APPEAL

 

          SLOMOES CORPORATION (PTY) LIMITED

          AND

          BONGANI S. DLAMINI N.O & FIVE OTHERS

 

C. J. LITTLER & COMPANY        HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDZE   

                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

THURSDAY 16 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

26.    CIV/APP. 77/2020 – APPEAL

 

          MYENGWA MACUBA SIBANDZE

          AND

          NATIONAL FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION OF ESWATINI

 

T. L. DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES      S. V. MDLADLA            ASSOCIATES

 

                                                                                                                                  

MONDAY 20 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

27.    CIV/APP. 92/2020 – APPEAL

 

          PITOLI SAMUEL SHABANGU & ANOTHER

          AND

          JOYCE SIBANDZE & THREE OTHERS

 

SIBUSISO B. SHONGWE            MOTSA MAVUSO ATTORNEYS

ASSOCIATES                                                                    

 

TUESDAY 21 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

28.    CIV/APP. 07/2021 – APPEAL

 

          SEITH NKAMBULE & TWO OTHERS

          AND

          MARIA THOKOZILE NKAMBULE

 

C. J. LITTLER & COMPANY       B. S. DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES

                            

 

         

                                               

 

WEDNESDAY 22 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

 

29.    CIV/APP. 02/2021 – APPEAL

 

          REJOICE THWALA-SUZMAN

          AND

          MACEY PHYLIS GROENING

 

S. V. MDLADLA &                             RODRIGUES & ASSOCIATES

ASSOCIATES                                                                                                                                                                                        

THURSDAY 23 SEPTEMBER 2021

 

30.    CIV/APP. 93/2020 – APPEAL

 

          ROYAL ESWATINI SUGAR CORPORATION LIMITED

          AND

          ACTING JUDGE MSIMANGO N.O AND FOUR OTHERS

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                     MAGAGULA

ATTORNEYS                                                            ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 04 OCTOBER 2021

 

31.    CIV/APP. 13/2021 – APPEAL

 

          MBHILIBHI (PTY) LTD T/A MBHILIBHI CIVIL

          AND

          ESOR CONSTRUCTION (PTY) LTD

 

WARING ATTORNEYS                                         CURRIE-WRIGHT

                                                                                     ASSOCIATES

 

TUESDAY 05 OCTOBER 2021

 

32.    CIV/APP. 03/2021 - APPEAL

 

          ISHMAEL MOHAMED

          AND

          REGINA MARIA SANTOS & TWO OTHERS

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                             MKHABELA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 06 OCTOBER 2021

 

33.    CIV/APP. 28/2020 – APPEAL

 

          MICHAEL THEMBA NSIBANDZE AND ANOTHER

          AND

          THE EXECUTOR N.O: ESTATE LATE PHILLIP & THREE

          OTHERS

 

S. V. MDLADLA &                            MTSHALI NGCAMPHALALA

ASSOCIATES                                      THWALA

 

 

THURSDAY 07 OCTOBER 2021

 

34.    CIV/APP. 07/2018 – REVIEW

 

          ALPHEOUS NXUMALO

          AND

          THE SWAZI OBSERVER (PTY) LTD T/A OBSERVER ON

          SUNDAY & TWO OTHERS

 

MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS          MAGAGULA & HLOPHE

                                                                   ATTORNEYS  

MONDAY 11 OCTOBER 2021

 

35.    CIV/APP. 61/2019 - APPEAL

 

          TEACHING SERVICE COMMISSION  & ANOTHER

          AND

         TIMOTHY TSABEDZE

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL                            MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

TUESDAY 12 OCTOBER 2021

 

36.    CIV/APP. 06/2021 - APPEAL

 

       LOBULAWU INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

       AND

      NGWANE MIILLS (PTY) LTD T/A FEEDMASTER

 

N. E. GININDZA                                                    BOXSHALL SMITH

ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 13 OCTOBER 2021

 

37.    CIV/APP. 42/2020 – APPEAL

 

        TQM INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

        AND

        SAMKELO ABEL DLAMINI

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                 M. H. MDLULI ATTORNEYS

 

 

THURSDAY 14 OCTOBER 2021

 

38.  CIV/APP. 11/2019 – APPLICATION

 

THE COMMANDER – UMBUTFO ESWATINI DEFENCE FORCE

          AND

          THEMBA MAZIYA

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL              L. M. DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES

                                                                                     

         

                                                           

MONDAY 18 OCTOBER 2021

 

39.    CIV/APP. 822/2016 – APPEAL

 

          KUKHANYA (PTY) LIMITED

          AND

          MBONGISENI MSIBI

 

S. V. MDLADLA &                                      MAGAGULA & HLOPHE

ASSOCIATES                                               ATTORNEYS

 

 TUESDAY 19 OCTOBER 2021

 

40.    CIV/APP. 63/2020 – APPEAL

 

          SWAZILAND COMMERCIAL & ALLIED WORKERS UNION

          ZANELE MAMBA & TWELVE OTHERS

          AND

          LEWIS STORES

 

B. S. DLAMINI                                           HENWOOD &  COMPANY

ATTORNEYS

 

                                                                                                                                                                                     

WEDNESDAY 20 OCTOBER 2021

 

41.    CIV/APP. 26/2020 – REVIEW

 

          CASHBUILD ESWATINI (PTY) LIMITED

          AND

          THEMBI PENELOPE MAGAGULA

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                  MKHWANAZI ATTORNEYS

ATTORNEYS                                                                                                                                 

THURSDAY 21 OCTOBER 2021

 

42.    CIV/APP. 91/2020 – APPEAL

 

          THULANI RUDOLF MASEKO

         AND

         ANDREAS LUKHELE N. O AND OTHERS

 

HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDZE        THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

ATTORNEYS                                         ROBINSON BERTRAMS

                                                                    ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 01 NOVEMBER 2021

 

43.    CIV/APP. 67/2009 – REVIEW

 

         NTSETSELELO HLATSHWAKO

          AND

COMMISSIONER GENERAL OF THE CORRECTIONAL SERVICES & ANOTHER

 

MOTSA MAVUSO ATTORNEYS              ATTORNEY GENERAL

        

TUESDAY 02 NOVEMBER 2021

 

44.    CIV/APP. 96/2020 – APPEAL

 

          SWAZILAND MEDICAL AID FUND

          AND

          THE CLINIC GROUP (PTY) LTD

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                        HENWOOD & COMPANY         

ATTORNEYS

 

                                                                                     

WEDNESDAY 03 NOVEMBER 2021

 

45.    CIV/APP. 75/2020 – APPEAL

 

          V & H SURGICAL & PATIENT CARE SUPPLIES LIMITED

          AND

          TOTAL CONSTRUCTION

 

N. E. GININDZA ATTORNEYS                              M. J. MANZINI &

                                                                                         ASSOCIATES

 

THURSDAY 04 NOVEMBER 2021

 

46.    CIV/APP. 17/2020 - REVIEW

 

          USA DISTILLERS

          AND

          IMPROCHEM (PTY) LIMITED

 

ROBINSON BERTRAMS                HENWOOD & COMPANY

ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 08 NOVEMBER 2021

 

47.    CIV/APP. 66/2019 - REVIEW

 

          KUKHANYA (PTY) LIMITED T/A KUKHANYA CIVIL

          ENGINEERING CONTRACTORS

          AND

          ABACUS CONSTRUCTION COST CONSULTANTS (PTY)

          LIMITED

 

S. V. MDLADLA ATTORNEYS                ROBINSON BERTRAMS

                                                                          ATTORNEYS

TUESDAY 09 NOVEMBER 2021

 

48.    CIV/APP. 25/2018 - APPEAL

 

          ESWATINI ELECTRICITY COMPANY

          AND

GIDEON GWEBU & ANOTHER

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                       MLANGENI & COMPANY

 ATTORNEYS                                             ROBINSON BERTRAMS

                                                                        ATTORNEYS                

WEDNESDAY 10 NOVEMBER 2021

 

49.    CIV/APP. 13/2018 – APPEAL

 

          THE SWAZI OBSERVER

          AND

          DR JOHANNES FUTHI DLAMINI & TWO OTHERS

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                  ROBINSON BERTRAMS

ATTORNEYS                                         ATTORNEYS

 

THURSDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2021

 

50.    CIV/APP. 15/2021 – APPEAL

 

          BHEKINKOSI MALAZA

          AND

          THANDAZILE GLORY DLUDLU

 

LUCAS BKS DLAMINI ATTORNEYS     NZIMA & ASSOCIATES      

                                                                         

 

 

MONDAY 15 NOVEMBER 2021

 

51.    CIV/APP. 24/2020 - REVIEW

 

          ESWATINI MEDICAL AID FUND

          AND

          MEDSCHEME ADMINISTRATORS SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

 

ROBINSON BERTRAMS                 MAGAGULA & HLOPHE

ATTORNEYS                                               ATTORNEYS

 

TUESDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2021

 

52.    CIV/APP. 62/2020 - REVIEW

 

NUR & SAM (PTY) LIMITED T/A BIG TREE FILLING STATION

AND

GALP ESWATINI (PTY) LIMITED

 

ROBINSON BERTRAMS                 MAGAGULA & HLOPHE

ATTORNEYS                                               ATTORNEYS

 

WEDNESDAY 17 NOVEMBER 2021

 

53.    CIV/APP. 65/2016 – APPEAL

 

          SANDILE THWALA N.O & EIGHT OTHERS

          AND

          MESHACK DLAMINI

 

HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS            MAGAGULA

ATTORNEY GENERAL                                                 & HLOPHE

DUNSEITH ATTORNEYS                                             ATTORNEYS

ROBINSON BERTRAMS ATTORNEYS 

 

THURSDAY 18 NOVEMBER 2021

 

54.    CIV/APP. 82/2020 – APPEAL

 

          MUZI P. SIMELANE

          AND

          THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF ESWATINI & TWO OTHERS

 

T. R. MASEKO ATTORNEYS                 ROBINSON BERTRAMS

                                                                             ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

_________________________________

REGISTRAR – SUPREME COURT