Supreme Court Second Session Final Roll 2019

Court: 
Supreme Court
Date: 
17 June 2019

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ESWATINI

 

 

SECOND SESSION COURT ROLL 2019

 

FINAL

 

 

 

TO:  Honourable Chief Justice

        Honourable Justices of the Supreme Court

        Honourable Justices of the High Court

        Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court

        Attorney General

        The Director of Public Prosecutions

        The Registrar of the High Court

        The Registrar of the Industrial Court

        The National Commissioner of Police

        The Commissioner General of Correctional Services

        The Law Society of the Kingdom of ESwatini

        Litigants in Person

 

NOTICE

 

        1.  ALL MATTERS WILL BE HEARD IN COURT A AND

             ATTORNEYS ARE ADVISED TO ATTEND COURT

             TIMEOUSLY.

 

        2.  ATTORNEYS ARE FURTHER ADVISED TO COMPLY

             STRICTLY WITH THE RULES OF COURT IN                         RESPECT OF THE RECORDS OF PROCEEDINGS,

             THE FILING OF HEADS OF ARGUMENT AND THE

             BUNDLE OF AUTHORITIES.

CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES

 

 

MONDAY 15 JULY 2019

 

 

1.  CIV/APP. 102/17

       

 

     IMVUSELELO INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

      AND                          

 

      USUTHU FOREST PRODUCTS LIMITED

 

                       

       

      MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS         HENWOOD AND                                                                              COMPANY

 

 

 

TUESDAY 16 JULY 2019

 

         

2.  CIV/ APP. 19/19

       

     REGIONAL EDUCATION OFFICER FOR HHOHHO REGION & ANOTHER  

 

      AND

                               

      MESHACK MAKHUBU & ANOTHER

 

 

     

      ATTORNEY GENERAL   LINDA DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 17 JULY 2019

 

 

3.  CIV/APP. 68/18

 

 

      XOLILE GAMA                          

 

      AND                                  

 

      FOOT THE BILL INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

                       

 

      LINDA DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES       HENWOOD AND                                                                               COMPANY

 

 

 

THURSDAY 18 JULY 2019

 

4.     CRIM/APP. 20/18

 

        MZWANDILE KHETHABAKHE SIYAYA

 

        AND

 

        REX

 

 

        DLAMINI-KUNENE ASSOCIATED     DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 23 JULY 2019

 

 

5.  CIV/APP. 100/17

 

 

        THE WEEKEND OBSERVER AND TWO OTHERS

 

        AND                                

 

        SIPHO MAKHABANE       

                               

 

 

        MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS            ROBINSON                                                                                       BERTRAM

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 24 JULY 2019

 

 

6.  CRIM/APP. 23/17

 

 

       BONGANI BAVUKILE DLAMINI

 

         AND                                       

 

         REX                                       

 

 

 

         XABA ATTORNEYS                                  DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

  

THURSDAY 25 JULY 2019

 

 

7.  CIV/APP. 53/17

 

 

         EKUHLAMUKENI FARMERS ASSOCIATION LIMITED

 

         AND       

                               

         SIPHO DLAMINI

 

 

                                       

         ZONKE MAGAGULA AND COMPANY          LUCAS BKS                                                             DLAMINI ATTORNEY

 

                                                                     

MONDAY 5 AUGUST 2019

 

 

8.  CRIM/APP. 01/19

 

 

        VUSANI MANQOBA MHLANGA

 

        AND                                

 

         REX                                       

 

 

        

         MABILA ATTORNEYS                      DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 6 AUGUST 2019

 

 

9.  CIV/APP. 02/19

 

 

        VICTOR TESAR

 

        AND                                

 

        ANITA TESAR

 

 

 

        GIGI A REID ATTORNEYS                 CURRIE-WRIGHT                                                                    ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 7 AUGUST 2019

 

 

10.  CIV/APP. 10/18

 

 

         PIUS HENWOOD N.O

 

         AND                                       

 

         EFFIE SONIA HENWOOD N.O AND ANOTHER

 

 

 

         HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE             SIBUSISO B.                         ATTORNEYS                                   SHONGWE AND                                                                         ASSOCIATES

               

 

 

THURSDAY 8 AUGUST 2019

 

 

11.  CRIM/APP. 19/18

 

 

        CHARLES JELE

 

        AND                                

 

        REX

 

 

 

       ROBINSON BERTRAM                       DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 12 AUGUST 2019

 

 

12.  CRIM/APP. 07/16

 

 

        BOY MCHUMANISI MKHATSHWA

 

       AND                                 

 

       REX

 

 

                                               

       S. B. MOTSA ATTORNEYS                 DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 13 AUGUST 2019

 

 

13.  CRIM/APP. 32/14

 

 

       BHUTIZA GIFT MATSEBULA

 

        AND                                

 

        REX

 

 

 

       LINDA DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES   DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 14 AUGUST 2019

 

 

14.  CIV/APP. 07/18

 

 

       THE SWAZI OBSERVER (PTY) LTD t/a OBSERVER ON    SATURDAY AND OTHERS

 

         AND                                       

 

         ALPHEOUS NXUMALO

 

                                               

 

        MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS               MTM                                                            NDLOVU ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 15 AUGUST 2019

 

 

 

15.  CRIM/APP. 36/14

 

 

       MFANASIBILI C. DLAMINI

 

        AND                                

       

        REX                                        

 

       

        S. A. NKOSI ATTORNEYS                 DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

          

MONDAY 19 AUGUST 2019

 

 

16.  CRIM/APP. 06/18

 

 

       DOCTOR VICTOR MKHABELA

 

        AND                                

 

        REX

               

               

               

         IN PERSON                                      DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 20 AUGUST 2019

 

 

17.  CRIM/APP. 15/17

 

 

       NKOSIVILE LUSHABA

 

       AND

                                       

       REX

 

 

                               

       T. M. BHEMBE ATTORNEYS             DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 21 AUGUST 2019

 

 

18.  CRIM/APP. 31/17

 

        BANELE MAMBA

 

        AND

 

       REX

 

 

 

       LINDA DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES                              DPP’s                                                                             CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 22 AUGUST 2019

 

 

19.  CRIM/APP. 12/17

 

 

       MACHAWE NKOSINATHI DLAMINI

 

        AND                                

 

       REX

 

 

 

       LINDA DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES                      DPP’s                                                                             CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 9 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

20.   CRIM/APP. 03/19

 

          DUMSANI MAXWELL KUNENE

 

        AND

 

        REX

 

 

        MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS                 DPP’s                                                                             CHAMBERS

                                                             

 

 

 

TUESDAY 10 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

21.  CIV/APP. 16/19

 

 

        ZINHLE MASEKO MDLULI

 

         AND                                       

 

        ALDONA LAPIDOS AND 2 OTHERS

 

 

 

        CJ LITTLER & CO.                   MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                           ATTORNEYS                                        

       

 

 

WEDNESDAY 11 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

22.  CRIM/APP. 07/16

 

 

      JOHANNES MFANUKHONA DLAMINI

 

      AND                                  

 

      REX

 

 

                                               

     LINDA DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES    DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 12 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

         

23.  CIV/APP. 03/19

 

 

         SIKHATSI DLAMINI

 

         AND                                       

 

         THE MAYOR - MBABANE MUNICIPAL COUNCIL OF       MBABANE &         OTHERS

 

 

                                                       

         MBUSO E. SIMELANE & ASSOCIATES     ROBINSON                                                                                       BERTRAM

 

 

 

MONDAY 16 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

24.  CIV/APP. 65/18

 

 

        CLEOPAS SIPHO DLAMINI

 

        AND                                

 

       CYNTHIA MPHOE DLAMINI (BORN SIMELANE)

 

 

                       

      L. R. MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES    SIMELANE MTSHALI

                                                             ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 17 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

25.  CIV/APP. 93/18 B

 

 

       ETHEL DLAMINI (BORN GULE)

 

       AND                                 

 

       PRINCE CHIEF GASAWANGWANE

 

       

 

     

       ZONKE MAGAGULA AND COMPANY            ATTORNEY                                                                                 GENERAL

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 18 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

26.  CIV/APP. 15/19

 

 

         LUMBELA GENERAL TRADING CC.

 

        AND

 

        SWAZI INDUSTRIES AGENCIES (PTY) LTD t/a BUILDERS DISCOUNT CENTRE AND ANOTHER

 

 

 

        M. S. DLAMINI LEGAL                WARING ATTORNEYS

 

 

THURSDAY 19 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

27.  CIV/APP. 96/17

 

 

         MINISTER OF TOURISM & AUTHORITY ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS AND ANOTHER

 

        AND                                

 

       STEPHEN ZUKE & ANOTHER

 

 

                                               

        ATTORNEY GENERAL                 ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

MONDAY 30 SEPTEMBER 2019

 

 

28.  CIV/APP. 08/16

 

 

       SIMANGA GINA

 

         AND

                                       

         CLEMENT SIMELANE

 

 

        S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES                 SITHOLE &                                                        MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 1 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

29.  CIV/APP. 63/15

 

 

        THE CHAIRPERSON OF KWALUSENI COUNCIL N. O

 

          AND

 

          MUSA MOSES ZWANE & OTHERS

 

 

 

          ATTORNEY GENERAL        NZIMA AND ASSOCIATES

                                                    HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE

                                                        ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 2 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

30.  CIV/APP. 21/19

 

 

          SWAZILAND PERISHABLE FOODS (PTY) LTD t/a FOOD LOVERS MARKET & ANOTHER

 

                AND

 

       VAN WYK & SONS (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

 

                       

 

       HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE                   BOXSHALL –   ATTORNEYS                                       SMITH ATTORNEYS

 

 

THURSDAY 3 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

31.  CIV/APP. 08/19

 

 

         SWAZILAND NATIONAL YOUTH COUNCIL             

 

         AND                               

 

         SWAZI JIVE ENTERTAINMENT (PTY) LTD AND ANOTHER

                                               

 

 

         GIGI A. REID ATTORNEYS                MAGAGULA AND                     HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 7 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

 

32.  CIV/APP. 06/19

 

 

        SIKHUMBUZO DLAMINI

 

        AND

 

        SAMUKELISIWE DLAMINI AND OTHERS

 

 

 

        B. S. DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES     MAGAGULA AND                                                             HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 8 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

33.  CIV/APP. 42/18

 

 

        ALAN ALEXANDER McGREGOR

 

        AND

 

        ROBERT CRABTREE & OTHERS

 

 

 

       MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE                       MAKHOSI C.         ATTORNEYS                             VILAKATI ATTORNEYS

 

                                                             MBUSO E. SIMELANE

                                                                  AND ASSOCIATES

                                                                                      

 

 

WEDNESDAY 9 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

34.  CIV/APP. 60/17

 

 

        MARTIN N. DLAMINI

 

         AND

 

         THE LAW SOCIETY OF SWAZILAND AND ANOTHER

 

 

 

        N. E. GININDZA ATTORNEYS     ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

THURSDAY 10 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

35.  CIV/APP. 95/17

 

 

         SIDUMO DLAMINI

 

         AND                                       

 

        BICON CONSULTING ENGINEERS (SWAZILAND) (PTY)   LTD

 

 

 

        S. V. MDLADLA AND ASSOCIATES            MAGAGULA AND                                                                     HLOPHE

                                                                    ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 14 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

36.   CIV/APP. 70/16                                              

 

       

          LOMDASHI LIMITED & ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        JOZANA SUPPLIERS (PTY) LTD AND OTHERS

 

 

 

        HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS   MAGAGULA                                                                           AND                                                                         HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 15 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

37.   CRIM/APP. 39/18

 

        HAPPY COLISILE MAVIMBELA

 

        AND

 

        BUYISILE MAVIMBELA AND ANOTHER

 

 

       

        ROBINSON BERTRAM         MAGAGULA AND SITHOLE

                                                     ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 16 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

38.   CIV/APP. 103/18

 

 

        RAMASHKA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

        AND

 

        ABAMBISANE CONSTRUCTION SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

 

 

 

        S. V. MDLADLA AND ASSOCIATES                  BOXSHALL –                                                                            SMITH

                                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 17 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

39.   CRIM/APP. 13/16

 

 

        THE COMMISSIONER OF ANTI-CORRUPTION        COMMISSION

 

        AND

 

        GIDEON DLAMINI AND OTHERS

 

 

        DPP’s CHAMBERS             MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 21 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

40.   CIV/APP. 11/19

 

 

        THE COMMANDER OF THE UMBUTFO ESWATINI DEFENCE FORCE AND ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        THEMBA MAZIYA

 

 

        ATTORNEY GENERAL           S. A. NKOSI ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 22 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

41.   CIV/APP. 112/18

 

 

        MANGWENI TINGOTINI FARMERS ASSOCIATION

 

        AND

 

        JOHN LUKHULENI AND OTHERS

 

 

 

        ZONKE MAGAGULA AND COMPANY          NZIMA AND                                                                                   ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 23 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

42.   CIV/APP. 109/18

 

        CHARLES ANDREW AND CINDY ANNE VAN WYK N.O

 

        AND

 

        ADRIAN JACOBUS VAN WYK & ANOTHER

 

 

 

        S. V. MDLADLA AND ASSOCIATES                          WARING                                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 24 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

43.   CIV/APP. 27/19

 

        JULIUS PATRICK NYONI

 

        AND

 

        THE TWELVE APOSTLES CHURCH IN CHRIST AND       OTHERS

 

 

        C. J. LITTLER AND COMPANY              M. V. DLAMINI                                                                                    ATTORNEYS

                                                            ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 28 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

44.   CIV/APP. 106/18

 

 

        ALPHEOUS LUSEKWANE DLAMINI

 

        AND

        NTOMBI ALICE DLAMINI

 

 

        M. S. DLAMINI LEGAL            MALINGA AND MALINGA                                                       INCORPORATED

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 29 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

45.   CIV/APP. 101/18

 

          IFTIKHAR AHMED & ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        QADIR IMRAN CHAUDHRY & ANOTHER

 

 

        SITHOLE AND MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS                   BEN J.                                                         SIMELANE ASSOCIATES

 

 

WEDNESDAY 30 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

46.   CIV/APP. 01/17

 

 

        SWAZI AUCTIONEERS (PTY) LIMITED AND OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT AND SAVINGS BANK

 

 

        L. R. MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES        MAGAGULA AND                                                             HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 31 OCTOBER 2019

 

 

47.   CIV/APP. 29/19

 

 

        NKOSINGIPHILE SHONGWE

 

        AND

 

UMBUTFO SWAZILAND DEFENCE FORCE AND ANOTHER

 

 

MUSA MOTSA ATTORNEYS       ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

MONDAY 4 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

48.   CIV/APP. 60/18

 

        NHLANHLA MACINGWANE

 

        AND

 

        FAMILY OF GOD CHURCH

 

 

 

        MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS          MKHWANAZI                                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 5 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

49.   CIV/APP. 57/18

 

 

        FRANCISCA THANDEKA SHAYO

        AND

 

        LINAH THEMBI MBHAMALI N. O AND OTHERS

 

 

        ROBINSON BERTRAM         S. M. KHOZA ATTORNEYS

                                                            ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

WEDNESDAY 6 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

50.   CIV/APP. 39/17

 

 

        SWAZILAND ELECTRICITY COMPANY

 

        AND

 

        GIRLIE THULIE SIBANDZE

 

 

        MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS          MKHWANAZI

                                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 7 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

51.   CIV/APP. 78/13

 

 

        SIMON VILANE N.O

 

        AND

 

        LIPNEY INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD AND OTHERS

 

 

        ROBINSON BERTRAM    C. J. LITTLER AND COMPANY

 

 

 

MONDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

52.   CIV/APP. 104/18

 

 

        WAKE-UP CONSTRUCTION (PTY) LTD & OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        MUZI NTSHALINTSHALI

 

       

        MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS           HOWE                                                                    MASUKU NSIBANDE                                                                            ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 12 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

53.   CIV/APP. 80/17

 

 

        THE CHAIRMAN, LIQUOR LICENSING BOARD

 

        AND

 

        THULANI MASEKO

 

 

        ATTORNEY GENERAL       T. R. MASEKO ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 13 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

54.   CIV/APP. 26/19

 

        ATLANTA PRODUCTS 9PTY) LTD

 

        AND

 

        SWAZI CABLES AND LIGHTING (PTY) LTD t/a AUTO       TECH SOLUTIONS

 

        SIMELANE MTSHALI ATTORNEYS                  MANYATSI &

                                                                          ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 14 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

55.   CIV/APP. 51/17

 

 

        PIETER PIETERSE & ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        ESWATINI ELECTRICITY COMPANY

 

 

        HENWOOD AND COMPANY   MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE

                                                      ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 18 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

56.   CIV/APP. 23/19

 

 

          NONTOKOZO MARILYN HADEBE N. O

 

        AND

 

        GRAHAM MANDA HADEBE

 

 

        MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS              LEO GAMA                                                                  AND ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 19 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

57.   CIV/APP. 47/18

 

 

        FIRST NATIONAL BANK SWAZILAND LIMITED AND        ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        SWAZILAND UNION OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS AND ALLIED WORKERS

 

 

        ROBINSON BERTRAM           M. HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 20 NOVEMBER 2019

 

 

58.   CIV/APP. 34/18

 

 

          THE PRIME MINISTER OF ESWATINI AND OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        MICHAEL VUSI MASILELA

 

 

        ATTORNEY GENERAL            ZONKE MAGAGULA AND                                                        COMPANY