Supreme Court Second Session Draft Roll

Court: 
Supreme Court
Date: 
02 July 2020

 

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ESWATINI

 

 

SECOND SESSION COURT ROLL 2020

 

DRAFT

 

TO: Honourable Chief Justice    

      Honourable Justices of the Supreme Court

      Honourable Justices of the High Court

      Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court

      Attorney General

      The Director of Public Prosecutions

      The Registrar of the High Court

      The Registrar of the Industrial Court

      The National Commissioner of Police

      The Commissioner General of Correctional    Services

      The Law Society of the Kingdom of ESwatini

      Litigants in Person

 

 

 

 

 

CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES

 

 

MONDAY 03 AUGUST 2020

 

 

1.  CIV/APP. 9/20: APPEAL

 

 

       ELLEN NOMSA DLAMINI

 

       AND

 

       NONHLANHLA PRINCESS DLAMINI & THREE       OTHERS

 

 

N. E. GININDZA ATTORNEYS         S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 04 AUGUST 2020

 

 

 

2.  CIV/APP. 41/20: APPEAL

 

 

        INDVUNA GANGILE HLATSHWAKO N.O & ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        ANDREAS DINGANE MAKHATHU & ANOTHER

 

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL              M. V. DLAMINI ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 05 AUGUST 2020

 

 

3.  CIV/APP. 86/19: APPEAL

 

 

       ABEL MPHILE SIBANDZE

 

        AND

 

        MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

NZIMA & ASSOCIATES                     MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 06 AUGUST 2020

 

 

4.  CIV/APP. 53/17: APPEAL

 

       EKUHLAMUKENI FARMERS ASSOCIATION

 

       AND

 

       SIPHO DLAMINI

 

 

ZONKE MAGAGULA & COMPANY       LUCAS B. K. DLAMINI                                                           ATTORNEYS                                                                      

                                                                       

 

                                             BEN J SIMELANE ATTORNEYS

 

MONDAY 10 AUGUST 2020

 

 

5.  CIV/APP. 17/20: APPEAL

 

 

       USA DISTILLERS (PTY) LTD

 

       AND

 

       IMPROCHEM (PTY) LTD

 

 

R. J. S. PERRY ATTORNEYS           HENWOOD & COMPANY

 

 

 

TUESDAY 11 AUGUST 2020

 

 

6.  CIV/APP. 22/20: APPEAL

 

 

       FAMILY OF GOD

 

       AND

 

       NHLANHLA MACINGWANE

 

 

MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS   MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 12 AUGUST 2020

 

 

7. CIV/APP. 29/20: APPEAL

 

 

       SWAZILAND AIRLINK

 

       AND

 

       NONHLANHLA SHONGWE & TWO OTHERS

 

 

  HENWOOD & COMPANY          T. R. MASEKO ATTORNEYS                                   

 

 

THURSDAY 13 AUGUST 2020

 

 

8.  CIV/APP. 77/19: APPEAL

 

 

       ESWATINI DEVELOPMENT AND SAVINGS BANK

 

       AND

 

       NSIBANDE MARACIAS

 

 

MLANGENI & COMPANY             B.S. DLAMINI ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

MONDAY 17 AUGUST 2020

 

 

9.  CIV APP. 63/19: APPEAL

 

 

        SOLOMON MTHETHWA

 

        AND                        

 

        SHISELWENI FORESTRY

 

 

                    

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS       CURRIE-WRIGHT ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

TUESDAY 18 AUGUST 2020

 

 

10.  CIV/APP. 03/20: APPEAL

 

 

     VUSI GININDZA & TWO OTHERS

 

      AND

                               

      GIDEON MHLONGO

 

 

 

MUSA M. SIBANDZE                  HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDZE ATTORNEYS                                 ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 19 AUGUST 2020

 

 

11.  CIV/APP. 89/19: APPEAL

 

 

      EMANGWENI HOLDINGS SUGAR ASSOCIATION (PTY)     

      LTD                           

 

      AND                                  

 

      KUBUTA AGRI DESIGN & CIVILS (PTY) LTD

 

                       

 

      B. S. DLAMINI ASSOCIATES                  HENWOOD AND                                                                                COMPANY

 

 

THURSDAY 20 AUGUST 2020

 

 

12.  CIV/APP. 04/20: APPEAL

 

 

        ALTA RAUTENBACH (NEE VAN ANTERWERPEN)

 

        AND

 

        PATIENCE SIKHONDZE & FIVE OTHERS

 

 

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                        DEM HLETA LEGAL

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 24 AUGUST 2020

 

 

13.  CIV/APP. 47/19: APPEAL

 

 

        SIBONGISENI KHUMALO

 

        AND                                

 

        COMMISSIONER OF POLICE & ANOTHER      

               

               

 

BEN J. SIMELANE ATTORNEYS         ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

TUESDAY 25 AUGUST 2020

 

 

14.  CIV/APP. 10/19: APPEAL

 

 

       EVOLUTION MEDIA (PTY) LTD T/A BRANDING DESIGN  

 

        AND                                

 

       GLOBEFLIGHT (SWD) PTY LTD

                               

 

 

MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS        SIMELANE MTSHALI                                                             ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 26 AUGUST 2020

 

 

15.  CIV/APP. 26/20: APPEAL

 

        CASHBUILD SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

 

        AND

 

        THEMBI PENELOPE MAGAGULA

 

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE               MKHWANAZI ATTORNEYS

ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 27 AUGUST 2020

 

 

16.  CIV/APP. 12/20: APPEAL

 

 

        SIPHO VIMBA MHLONGO-MATSE

 

        AND

 

        GUGU MHLONGO & SIX OTHERS

 

 

 

MLANGENI & COMPANY                   MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 14 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

17.  CIV/APP. 11/20: APPEAL

 

 

        KUKHANYA (PTY) LTD

 

        AND

 

        MAPUTO PLANTHIRE (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

 

 

 

S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES     HENWOOD & COMPANY

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 15 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

18.  CIV/APP. 56/13: APPLICATION

 

 

        NICHOLAS MANANA & TWO OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        ESWATINI GOVERNMENT & THREE OTHERS

 

 

 

MKHABELA ATTORNEYS                   ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

  

WEDNESDAY 16 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

19.  CIV/APP. 06/18: APPEAL

 

 

       LOWVELD TRUCKING (PTY) LTD

 

        AND                                

 

        SWAZILAND RAILWAY

 

 

 

MABILA ATTORNEYS                          ROBINSON BERTRAM                                                            ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 17 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

20.  CIV/APP. 10/20: APPEAL

 

 

       LUCKY’S ARK INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

 

       AND                                 

 

       TQM INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

 

                                               

 

MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS                 BEN J. SIMELANE &

                                                              ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

MONDAY 21 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

 

21.  CIV/APP. 25/18: REVIEW

 

 

       ESWATINI ELECTRICITY COMPANY

 

        AND                                

       

       GIDEON GWEBU & ANOTHER

 

                                               

       

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                    MLANGENI & COMPANY ATTORNEYS

 

 

          

TUESDAY 22 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

22.  CIV/APP. 15/19: APPEAL

 

 

       SIBONISO CLEMENT DLAMINI

 

        AND                                

 

        REX

 

               

               

HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE                      DPP’s CHAMBERS

ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 23 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

23.  CIV/APP. 27/20: APPEAL

 

 

       A.B.C MINISTRIES & TWO OTHERS

 

       AND

                                       

       ROSE RAUTENBACH & THREE OTHERS

 

 

                               

BOXSHALL-SMITH ATTORNEYS        ROBINSON BERTRAM                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

                                                            ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

THURSDAY 24 SEPTEMBER 2020

 

 

24.  CIV/APP. 35/20: APPEAL

 

 

        SIMANGA MAKHUBU

 

       AND

 

      FERNANDO ROCHA

 

 

 

 BOXSHALL-SMITH ATTORNEYS        M.S. DLAMINI LEGAL

 

 

 

MONDAY 05 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

25.  CIV/APP. 53/19: REVIEW

 

 

       TUNTEX TEXTILE (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

 

       AND                                 

 

       ESWATINI GOVERNMENT & ANOTHER

 

 

 

S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES         ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 06 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

26.  CIV/APP. 37/19: APPEAL

 

 

          LOBUSUKU MASUKU & OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        NELISIWE ZANELE DE SOUSA

 

 

 

KHUMALO ATTORNEYS        HLABANGANE & ASSOCIATES

                                              ATTORNEY GENERAL

                                      ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS

                                             S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES

                                                                  

 

WEDNESDAY 07 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

27.  CIV/APP. 06/19: APPEAL

 

 

        SIKHUMBUZO DLAMINI

 

         AND                               

 

        SAMKELISIWE DLAMINI & TWO OTHERS

 

 

 

B. S. DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES     MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                          ATTORNEYS

 

                                                         ATTORNEY GENERAL                                      

 

THURSDAY 08 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

28.  CIV/APP. 87/19: APPEAL

 

 

      MOSES MOTSA T/A EVUKUZENZELE

 

      AND                                  

 

      FARM CHEMICAL LIMITED

 

 

 

NZIMA AND ASSOCIATES                   WARING ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

MONDAY 12 OCTOBER 2020

 

         

29.  CIV/APP. 97/16: APPEAL

 

 

        JACOB YENDE

 

         AND                               

 

        NGONINI ESTATE (A division of United Plantation)

        Swaziland Limited

 

 

 

MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS        HENWOOD &                                                                           COMPANY

 

 

 

TUESDAY 13 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

30.  CIV/APP. 18/20: APPEAL

 

 

        SWAZILAND NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF TEACHER’S    BURIAL SCHEME

 

        AND                                

 

       SENIOR MAGISTRATE MBATHA & TWO OTHERS

 

 

 

DLAMINI-KUNENE ASSOCIATES        ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

                                              BEN J SIMELANE ATTORNEYS

 

WEDNESDAY 14 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

31.  CRIM/APP. 18/19: APPEAL

 

 

       SIBUSISO KUKUZA DLAMINI

 

       AND                                 

 

       REX

 

 

 

MABILA ATTORNEYS                              DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 15 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

32.  CRIM/APP. 13/20: APPEAL

 

 

        MBONGENI MAZWI MNGOMETULU

 

        AND

 

        REX

 

 

 

IN PERSON                                               DPP’s CHAMBERS

                                                       

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 19 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

33.  CIV/APP. 14/20: APPEAL

 

 

         SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION & ANOTHER

 

        AND                                

 

       NONHLANHLA SHONGWE & TWO OTHERS

 

 

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                            THOMO & MAZIYA

ATTORNEYS                                           ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 20 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

34.  CRIM/APP. 12/19: APPEAL

 

 

       MXOLISI WANDILE MAHLALELA

 

        AND

                                       

        REX

 

 

 

MABILA ATTORNEYS                              DPP’s CHAMBERS

                                               

 

 

WEDNESDAY 21 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

35.  CIV/APP. 07/20: APPEAL

 

 

        DPP

 

         AND

 

        LINDA MAGAGULA & ANOTHER

 

 

 

DPP’s CHAMBERS                     V. Z. DLAMINI ATTORNEYS      

                                                   

 

 

THURSDAY 22 OCTOBER 2020

 

 

36.  CRIM/APP. 04/17: APPEAL

 

 

         REX

 

                AND

 

       MUSA FAKUDZE & OTHERS

 

                       

 

DPP’s CHAMBERS                               MABILA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 02 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

37.  CRIM/APP. 18/19: REVIEW

 

 

         MUZI BONGANI SIKHONDZE         

 

         AND                               

 

         REX

                                               

 

 

LINDA DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES              DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 03 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

 

38.  CIV/APP. 24/20: APPEAL

 

 

        MEDSCHEME ADMINISTRATORS SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

 

        AND

 

        SWAZILAND MEDICAL AID FUND & ANOTHER

 

 

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                      MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS                                        ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 04 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

39.  CIV/APP. 65/16: APPEAL

 

 

        MANZINI CITY COUNCIL

 

       AND

 

      MESHACK DLAMINI & THREE OTHERS

 

 

HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS       MAGAGULA &

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL                                    HLOPHE

 

DUNSEITH ATTORNEYS                                 ATTORNEYS

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS

 

 

                                                                  

THURSDAY 05 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

40.  CIV/APP. 41/12: REVIEW

 

 

        NTOKOZO MALINGA

 

         AND

 

        REX

 

 

LINDA DLAMINI ASSOCIATES                  DPP’s CHAMBERS

                                                           

MONDAY 09 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

41.  CIV/APP. 68/19: REVIEW

 

 

         JOHANE TSABEDZE T/A JOHANE T.T TRANSPORT

 

         AND                               

 

        MAGMA HOLDINGS (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

 

 

 

DLAMINI-KUNENE ASSOCIATES               HENWOOD &                                                                          COMPANY

                                                                    

 

                                          MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 10 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

42.  CRIM/APP. 02/17: REVIEW                                         

 

       

          TONY ZOLA MAMBA

 

        AND

 

        REX

 

 

 

IN PERSON                                               DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 11 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

43.  CIV/APP. 66/19: APPEAL

 

 

        KUKHANYA (PTY) LTD T/A KUKHANYA CIVIL   ENGINEERING CONTRACTORS

 

        AND

 

        ABACUS CONSTRUCTION COST CONSULTANT (PTY)       LTD

 

 

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM              S. V. MDLADLA ASSOCIATES

ATTORNEYS                                                                                      

 

THURSDAY 12 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

44.  CIV/APP. 13/18: APPEAL

 

 

        THE SWAZI OBSERVER NEWSPAPER (PTY) LTD

        T/A OBSERVER ON SATURDAY & TWO OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        DR. JOHANNES FUTHI DLAMINI

 

 

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                       ROBINSON BERTRAM

ATTORNEYS                                       ATTORNEYS                                  

MONDAY 16 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

45.  CIV/APP. 79/19: APPEAL

 

 

        RUDOLPH INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

 

        AND

 

        CHRISTOPHER A.M DRAPPER & THREE OTHERS

 

 

 

S. V. MDLADLA ASSOCIATES         HENWOOD & COMPANY

 

 

 

TUESDAY 17 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

46.  CIV/APP. 62/19: APPEAL

 

 

        JOHAN JACOB RUDOLPH & ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        KANHYM ESTATES (PTY) LTD & TWO OTHERS

 

 

 

CURRIE-WRIGHT ASSOCIATES         ROBINSON BERTRAM                                                            ATTORNEYS            

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 18 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

47.  CIV/APP. 19/20: APPEAL

 

 

        MABANDLA MANYATSI

 

        AND

 

        MHLUPHEKI MALINGA

 

 

 

MANYATSI & ASSOCIATES     L. G. SHONGWE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 19 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

48.  CIV/APP. 25/20: APPEAL

 

 

        ANDREW DLAMINI

 

        AND

 

        THOKOZANI KHUMALO & ANOTHER

 

 

 

MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS                ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                            ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 23 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

49.  CIV/APP. 80/19: APPEAL

 

 

        SIBONISO CLEMENT DLAMINI

 

        AND

 

        THE CHIEF JUSTICE & TWO OTHERS

 

 

 

T.R. MASEKO ATTORNEYS                ROBINSON BERTRAM                                                            ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 24 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

50.  CIV/APP. 21/20: APPEAL

 

 

        THE MINISTER OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVELOPMENT

 

         AND

                               

         VIP DRY CLEANERS (PTY) LTD & FOUR OTHERS

 

 

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL               NTSHANGASE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

                                       

WEDNESDAY 25 NOVEMBER 2020

 

 

51.  CIV/APP. 78/19: APPEAL

 

 

        NHLANGANO CASINO ROYALE PTY LTD

 

        AND                                

 

       CONCILIATION MEDIATION & ARBITRATION

       COMMISSION & OTHERS                        

 

 

         

MUSA SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS               XABA ATTORNEYS