Supreme Court Second Session Draft Roll

Court: 
Supreme Court
Date: 
14 June 2018

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF ESWATINI

 

 

SECOND SESSION COURT ROLL 2018

 

FIRST DRAFT

 

TO:  Honourable Chief Justice

        Honourable Justices of Appeal

        Honourable Justices of the High Court

        Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court

        Attorney General

        The Director of Public Prosecutions

        The Registrar of the High Court

        The Registrar of the Industrial Court

        The National Commissioner of Police

        The Commissioner General of Correctional Services

        The Law Society of the Kingdom of ESwatini

        Litigants in Person

 

 

NOTICE

 

        1.  ALL MATTERS WILL BE HEARD IN COURT A AND

             ATTORNEYS ARE ADVISED TO ATTEND COURT

             TIMEOUSLY.

 

        2.  ATTORNEYS ARE FURTHER ADVISED TO COMPLY

             STRICTLY WITH THE RULES OF COURT IN                         RESPECT OF THE RECORDS OF PROCEEDINGS,

             THE FILING OF HEADS OF ARGUMENT AND THE

             LIST OF AUTHORITIES.

 

 

CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES

 

 

MONDAY 16 JULY 2018

 

 

1.  CRIM/APP. 1/18

       

 

     DILAWAR HUSSAIN

 

      AND                                  

 

      REX

 

                            

         

      PILISO ATTORNEYS                                                DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

2.  CRIM/APP. 10/16

 

 

         DUMISA TREVOR DLAMINI

 

         AND                                        

 

         REX

 

     

         IN PERSON                                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

TUESDAY 17 JULY 2018

 

         

3.  CRIM/ APP. 30/17

       

     SENZO MATSENJWA       

 

      AND                                  

      REX

 

     

      SITHOLE MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS                        DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

4.  CIV/APP. 85/17

 

 

        THABSILE MALINGA

 

        AND                                         

 

        RODGERS MABHOYANE DUPONT AND ANOTHER

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 18 JULY 2018

 

 

5.  CRIM/APP. 22/17

 

 

      DPP                                  

 

      AND                                            

 

      STANLEY NHLALAKAFU AND 3 OTHERS

 

                            

 

      DPP’s CHAMBERS                          BEN J SIMELANE & ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

6.  CIV/APP. 2/18

 

 

        FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATORY AUTHORITY

 

        AND                                         

 

        GOODMAN DLAMINI AND 3 OTHERS

 

                                                         

        ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS         B. S. DLAMINI ATTORNEY

 

 

 

THURSDAY 19 JULY 2018

 

 

7.  CIV/APP. 102/17

 

 

         IMVUSELELO INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

 

         AND                                        

 

         USUTHU FOREST PRODUCTS LTD

 

 

         MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS            HENWOOD ATTORNEYS

 

 

8.  CRIM/APP. 02/18

 

 

      THEMBINKOSI THUMBELA

 

      AND

 

       REX

 

 

      IN PERSON                                                              DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 23 JULY 2018

 

 

9.  CRIM/APP.06/18

 

 

      DOCTOR VICTOR MKHABELA

 

        AND                                         

 

        REX

 

         

        IN PERSON                                                            DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

10.  CRIM/APP. 31/17

 

 

         BANELE MAMBA           

 

         AND                               

 

         REX                     

 

 

         MABILA ATTORNEYS                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

TUESDAY 24 JULY 2018

 

 

11.  CRIM/APP. 27/15

 

 

        ZANELE VILAKATI

 

        AND                                         

 

        REX                                          

 

 

        BEN J SIMELANE & ASSOCIATES                        DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

12.  CIV/APP. 01/17

 

 

        SWAZI AUCTIONEERS (PTY) LTD AND 5 OTHERS

 

        AND                                         

 

        THE SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT & SAVINGS BANK

 

                                                         

        L. R. MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES                     MAGAGULA HLOPHE                                                                                 ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 25 JULY 2018

 

 

13.  CRIM/APP.09/16

 

 

       PHUMLANI SIKELELA DLAMINI

 

         AND                                        

 

         REX                                         

 

 

         IN PERSON                                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

14.  CIV/APP. 56/13

 

 

       NICHOLAS MANANA AND 2 OTHERS

 

         AND

                                               

         ACTING PRESIDENT OF THE INDUSTRIAL COURT AND 2 OTHERS

                                                         

                                                                               ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

  

THURSDAY 26 JULY 2018

 

 

15.  CRIM/APP. 09/18

 

 

         MFANASIBILI C. DLAMINI

 

         AND  

                                     

         REX

 

                                               

         IN PERSON                                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

16.  CIV/APP. 10/18

 

 

       EFFIE SONYA HENWOOD N. O

 

        AND

 

        PIUS HENWOOD N. O

 

     

        DUNSEITH ATTORNEYS                       HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE

                                                                     ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 6 AUGUST 2018

 

 

17.  CRIM/APP. 20/17

 

 

        JOSEPH BHEKI DLAMINI AND ANOTHER

 

        AND                                         

 

         REX                                         

 

        

         NKOSI ATTORNEYS                                             DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

18.  CRIM/APP. 05/17

 

 

        DERRICK DLAMINI                  

 

        AND                                         

 

        REX

 

 

       IN PERSON                                                             DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 7 AUGUST 2018

 

 

19.  CRIM/APP. 12/16

 

 

        VARAM ABSALOM SKHOSANA

 

        AND                                         

 

        REX

 

        IN PERSON                                                            DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

20.  CRIM/APP. 07/18

 

 

       NHLASE ANTHONY NXUMALO

 

        AND

 

        REX

 

       IN PERSON                                                             DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 8 AUGUST 2018

 

 

21.  CRIM/APP. 07/16

 

 

         BOY MCHUMANISI MKHATSHWA

 

         AND                                        

 

         REX

 

 

         IN PERSON                                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

22.  CRIM/APP.03/18

 

 

         DUMISA PHILEMON MNISI AND ANOTHER

 

         AND                                        

 

         REX                               

 

        ZONKE MAGAGULA & COMPANY                         DPP’s CHAMBERS

THURSDAY 9 AUGUST 2018

 

 

23.  CIV/APP. 65/17

 

 

        NORMAN NGCOBO

 

        AND                                         

 

        ELIJA TUTWANE DLAMINI AND 2 OTHERS

 

 

       DLAMINI KUNENE ATTORNEYS              LEO GAMA & ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

24.  CIV/APP. 98/17

 

 

       SWAZILAND REVENUE AUTHORITY

 

         AND                                         

 

         CMC SWAZILAND

 

                            

                                                                           HENWOOD ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 13 AUGUST 2018

 

 

25.  CIV/APP. 07/18

 

 

        ALPHEOUS NXUMALO

 

       AND                                          

 

       THE SWAZILAND OBSERVER (PTY) LTD T/A OBSERVER ON

       SATURDAY AND 2 OTHERS

 

                                                         

       MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS        MAGAGULA HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

26.  CIV/APP. 15/18

 

 

       SOLOMON SONTO AND ANOTHER  

 

         AND

 

         HLELEKILE ZWANE                

 

                                               

 

        C. J. LITTLER ATTORNEYS     SITHOLE & MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 14 AUGUST 2018

 

 

27.  CIV/APP. 18/18

 

 

       SWAZILAND PERISHABLE FOODS (PTY) LTD T/A FOOD LOVERS

         MARKET AND 3 OTHERS

 

         AND                                        

 

         SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION

 

 

         HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE                         ROBINSON BERTRAM                       

         ATTORNEYS                                                  ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

28.  CIV/APP. 77/16

 

 

        FRANCE DUPONT

 

          AND

 

          M. A. RANCHES (PTY) LTD AND 4 OTHERS

 

 

         N E GININDZA ATTORNEYS                           ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 15 AUGUST 2018

 

 

29.  CIV/APP. 19/18

 

 

       BASITE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION (PTY) LTD

 

         AND                                        

 

         EUROPA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

                                                         

 

        MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS                        SB MOTSA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

30.  CIV/APP. 100/17

 

 

        WEEKEND OBSERVER & 2 OTHERS

 

        AND   

                                     

        SIPHO MAKHABANE

                  

        MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS             ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                                ATTORNEY

 

THURSDAY 16 AUGUST 2018

 

 

 

31.  CIV/APP. 21/18

 

 

       NGWANE MILLS (PTY) LTD

 

        AND                                         

 

        SWAZILAND REVENUE AUTHORITY

                                                         

 

        THE COMMISSIONER

 

         

        ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS     S. V. MDLADLA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

32.  CIV/APP. 87/17

 

 

        ADJ AND ASSOCIATES INCORPORATED (PTY) LTD

 

        AND                                         

 

        STANDARD BANK SWAZILAND LIMITED AND ANOTHER

 

                                                         

        MBUSO E. SIMELANE & ASSOCIATES           ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                               ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

          

MONDAY 20 AUGUST 2018

 

 

33.  CIV/APP. 22/18

 

 

         THOKOZILE LINDIWE VILAKATI

 

         AND                                        

 

         THE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS AND 2 OTHERS

 

 

         ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS                    DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

34.  CIV/APP. 13/18

 

 

         THE SWAZI OBSERVER NEWSPAPER T/A THE OBSERVER ON

         SATURDAY AND 2 OTHERS

 

         AND                                        

 

         DR. JAHANNES FUTHI DLAMINI

                                                         

 

        MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS             ROBINSON BERTRAM                     ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 21 AUGUST 2018

 

 

35.  CIV/APP. 62/17

 

 

       SIBONISO CLEMENT DLAMINI

 

       AND

                                               

       THABISO HLANZE AND ANOTHER

                                     

                                                            MAGAGULA HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

36.  CIV/APP. 04/16

 

 

       MOSES MOTSA AND ANOTHER

 

         AND                                        

 

         LIONEL OSWALD REID AND ANOTHER

 

 

         NZIMA AND ASSOCIATES                      NKOMONDZE ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 22 AUGUST 2018

 

 

37.  CIV/APP. 47/17

 

        SUFIAW

 

        AND

 

       FIRST NATIONAL BANK

 

 

       ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

38.  CIV/APP. 59/17

 

 

        SIFISO VUSUMUZI SIKHONDZE

 

          AND                                       

 

          THE MUNICIPAL COUNCIL OF MBABANE AND 2 OTHERS

 

 

THURSDAY 23 AUGUST 2018

 

 

39.  CIV/APP. 68/15

 

 

        BEAUTY BUILD CONSTRUCTION

 

          AND                                       

 

          MUZI P. SIMELANE T/A MP SIMELANE ATTORNEYS AND 2           OTHERS

 

 

          ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS    HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE

                                                                      ATTORNEYS

 

 

40.  CIV/APP. 36/17

 

 

      ARMILDA LAIDAS T/A JUST KIDS    

 

       AND                                          

 

       THE GABLES (PTY) LTD

                  

 

      

                                                                                WARING ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 10 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

41.  CIV/APP. 57/16

 

 

         S. V INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD AND ANOTHER

 

         AND                                        

 

        WORLD WIDE INTERNATIONAL SECURITY SERVICE (PTY) LTD                 T/A SECURITY SERVICES (PTY) LTD

 

                                                         

         NZIMA AND ASSOCIATES                       C Z DLAMINI ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

42.  CIV/APP. 53/17

 

 

        EKUHLAMUKENI FARMERS ASSOCIATION

 

        AND   

 

        SIPHO DLAMINI

                            

 

        ZONKE MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS                 LUCAS B. K DLAMINI

                                                                                 ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 11 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

 

43.  CIV/APP. 73/16

 

 

         THE PRIME MINISTER AND OTHERS

 

         AND                                        

 

         THULANI RUDOLF MASEKO AND OTHERS

 

                                                         

         ATTORNEY GENERAL’S CHAMBERS              LEO GAMA & ASSOCIATES

 

 

WEDNESDAY 12 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

         

44.  CIV/APP. 73/16

 

 

         THE PRIME MINISTER AND OTHERS

 

         AND                                        

 

         THULANI RUDOLF MASEKO AND OTHERS

 

                                                         

         ATTORNEY GENERAL’S CHAMBERS              LEO GAMA & ASSOCIATES

 

 

THURSDAY 13 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

45.  CIV/APP. 103/17

 

 

         NIHON INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

         AND                                        

 

         TILLY S. INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

                                               

 

        T. L DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES                MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS

46.  CIV/APP. 12/18

 

 

        THE ROTARY CLUB

 

        AND                                         

 

        TIHLOBOTAKHE ZULU            

 

     

       DUNSEITH ATTORNEYS                B. S. DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

MONDAY 17 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

47.  CIV/APP. 105/17

 

 

        MFANUKHONA MADUMA AND 2 OTHERS

 

        AND                                         

 

       JUNIOR ACHIEVEMT SWAZILAND

                            

      ATTORNEY GENERAL’S CHAMBERS                 MAGAGULA HLOPHE

                                                                                 ATTORNEYS

 

 

48.  CIV/APP. 20/18

 

 

       DUPS PROPERTIES (PTY) LTD

 

         AND                                        

 

         NCAMISO MANANA N. O AND 2 OTHERS

                                     

        ZONKE MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS      MANYATSI AND ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 18 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

49.  CIV/APP. 96/17

 

 

       MINISTER OF TOURISM AND ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS AND

       ANOTHER

 

       AND                                          

 

       STEPHEN ZUKE AND ANOTHER

         

 

       ATTORNEY GENERAL’S CHAMBERS              ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                                ATTORNEYS

                                                                     C J LITTLER AND COMPANY

 

 

50.  CIV/APP. 91/16

 

 

         DERRICK DUBE

 

         AND                                         

 

         EZULWINI MUNICIPALITY AND 6 OTHERS

 

 

        MAGAGULA HLOPHE ATTORNEYS      S. V. MDLADLA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 19 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

51.  CIV/APP. 08/16

 

 

         SIMANGA GINA

 

        AND

 

        CLEMENT SIMELANE

 

 

        S. V. MDLADLA                           SITHOLE MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS

 

 

52.  CIV/APP. 06/18

 

 

         LOWVELD TRUCKING (PTY) LTD

 

         AND                                        

 

        SWAZILAND RAILWAY             

 

 

        MABILA ATTORNEYS                ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 20 SEPTEMBER 2018

 

 

53.  CIV/APP. 03/17

 

 

         MFANUFIKILE PATRICK DLAMINI AND ANOTHER

 

         AND                                        

 

        ZODWA DLAMINI AND 4 OTHERS

 

                                                         

        C. J LITTLER & COMPANY       MBUSO E. SIMELANE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

 

 

54.  CIV/APP. 67/17

 

 

        DARYALI INVESTMENTS

 

        AND                                         

 

        BARAKA INVESTMENTS

 

 

                                                         

        NKOMONDZE ATTORNEYS                 S. V. MDLADLA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

MONDAY 1 OCTOBER 2018

 

 

55.  CIV/APP. 11/18

 

 

       THABSILE THANDEKA KHOZA

 

         AND

                                               

         KHANYISILE BONISIWE MAKHANYA AND 5 OTHERS

 

 

         S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES    L. R. MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

56.  CIV/APP. 03/18

 

 

       PATSON DLAMINI AND ANOTHER

 

         AND                                        

 

         NORMAN JABULANI MASEKO AND 2 OTHERS

 

                                                         

                                                                                 MABILA ATTORNEYS

                                                 SIBUSISO B. SHONGWE & ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

TUESDAY 2 OCTOBER 2018

 

 

57.  CRIM/APP. 10/18

 

 

        MCOLISI SICELO DLAMINI

 

          AND

 

          REX

 

 

         IN PERSON                                                          DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

58.  CRIM/APP. 11/18

 

 

         BHEKITHEMBA NDZINISA

 

         AND

 

         REX

 

     

         IN PERSON                                                          DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 3 OCTOBER 2018

 

 

59.  CRIM/APP. 27/17

 

 

        CHEN BEISHUN AND ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        REX                      

 

 

       MABILA ATTORNEYS                                             DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

60.  CRIM/APP. 17/17

 

 

       MEFIKA MATSEBULA AND ANOTHER

 

        AND

 

        REX

 

 

        JUSTICE M MAVUSO ATTORNEYS                       DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 4 OCTOBER 2018

 

 

61.  CRIM/APP. 15/17

 

 

         NKOSIVILE GOODWILL LUSHABA            

 

         AND                                        

 

         REX                                         

 

 

         MABILA ATTORNEYS                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

62.  CIV/APP. 23/16

 

 

        BEAUTY PAT SIHLONGONYANE

 

        AND                                         

 

        XOLILE SIHLONGONYANE T/A THE PROPERTY SHOP AND 3

        OTHERS

 

 

        MOTSA MAVUSO ATTORNEYS                        MABILA ATTORNEYS

                                                         ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 8 OCTOBER 2018

 

 

63.  CIV/APP. 68/17

 

        DOCTOR HLATJWAKO

 

        AND

 

        DOUGLAS LUSHABA AND 5 OTHERS

        N E GININDZA ATTORNEYS                        ATTORNEY GENERAL’S                                                                              CHAMBERS

 

64.  CIV/APP. 23/18

 

 

       MAURISWAZI INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD AND THREE OTHERS

 

        AND

 

        SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION

 

      

        HOWE MASUKU ATTORNEYS                        ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 9 OCTOBER 2018

 

65.  CIV/APP. 26/18

 

 

        CENTRAL BANK OF SWAZILAND

 

        AND

 

        POLYCARP MFANASIBILI DLAMINI AND 6 OTHERS

        M J MANZINI AND ASSOCIATES                            L R MAMBA AND

                                                                                        ASSOCIATES

 

66.  CIV/APP. 107/17

 

 

        THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

        AND

 

        DUMSANI TSELA T/A LENDZE TRANSPORT

        ATTORNEY GENERAL’S CHMABERS              ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 10 OCTOBER 2018

 

 

67.  CIV/APP. 29/18

 

 

        THE ATTORENY GENERAL

 

         AND

 

         HOWARD PHOKWANE NKAMBULE

 

 

        ATTORNEY GENERAL’S CHAMBERS                    RODRIGUES AND

                                                                                      ASSOCIATES

68.  CIV/APP. 80/17

 

 

       THULANI RUDOLF MASEKO

 

        AND

 

        THE CHAIRMAN, LIQUOR LICENSING BOARD AND ANOTHER

 

 

        T R MASEKO ATTORNEYS                           ATTORNEY GENERAL’S                                                                             CHAMBERS

 

 

THURSDAY 11 OCTOBER 2018

 

69.  CIV/APP. 106/17

 

 

         MANGALISO DLAMINI

 

         AND                                        

 

        SIKHATSI DLAMINI N. O

 

 

 

70.  CIV/APP. 99/17

 

 

       JABULILE ZANDILE SHONGWE

 

        AND                                         

 

        PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE INDUSTRIAL COURT AND ANOTHER

                                     

                  

         ZONKE MAGAGULA & COMPANY                 ROBINSON BERTRAM                                                                                 ATTORNEYS