Supreme Court First Session Final Roll

Court: 
Supreme Court
Date: 
31 January 2020

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF ESWATINI 

 

FIRST SESSION COURT ROLL 2020

 

FINAL

 

TO: Honourable Chief Justice

      Honourable Justices of Appeal

      Honourable Justices of the High Court

      Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court

      Attorney General

      The Director of Public Prosecutions

      The Registrar of the High Court

      The Registrar of the Industrial Court

      The National Commissioner of Police

      The Commissioner General of Correctional       Services

      The Law Society of the Kingdom of Eswatini

      Litigants in Person

 

 

NOTICE

 

  1. ALL MATTERS WILL BE HEARD IN COURT A AND ATTORNEYS ARE ADVISED TO ATTEND COURT TIMEOULY.

 

 

  1. ATTORNEYS ARE FURTHER ADVISED TO COMPLY STRICTLY WITH THE RULES OF COURT IN RESPECT OF THE RECORDS OF PROCEEDINGS, THE FILING OF HEADS OF ARGUMENT AND THE BUNDLE OF AUTHORITIES

 

 

 

 

 

             

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CIVIL AND CRIMINAL CASES

 

MONDAY 17 FEBRUARY 2020

 

1.      CRIM/APP. 9/19 – APPEAL

 

          ALEX POUND LANGA

          AND

          REX

 

LINDA DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES                    DPP’S CHAMBERS

 

  1.  CIVIL/APP.85/19- APPEAL

 

XOLILE NTOMBIKAYISE SHABANGU- ZWANE

AND

PITOLI SHABANGU & 8 OTHERS

 

MOTSA MAVUSO ATTORNEYS     HLABANGANA & 

                                                                    ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

TUESDAY 18 FEBRUARY 2020

 

3.      CRIM/APP. 8/19 – APPEAL

 

          NDUMISO GAGASHI SIMELANE & ANOTHER

          AND

          REX

 

MABILA ATTORNEYS                                           DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 19 FEBRUARY 2020

 

4.      CRIM/APP. 7/19 – APPEAL

 

          MONDLI MKOKO

          AND

          REX

 

MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS         DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 20 FEBRUARY 2020

 

5.      CRIM/APP. 12/19 - APPEAL

 

          MXOLISI WANDILE MAHLALELA

          AND

          REX

 

MABILA ATTORNEYS                       DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

MONDAY 2 MARCH 2020

 

6.      CIV/APP. 53/17 – REVIEW

 

      EKUHLAMKENI FARMERS ASSOCIATION

      AND

      SIPHO DLAMINI

 

ZONKE MAGAGULA & CO.                         LUCAS B. K. DLAMINI                                                                     ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 3 MARCH 2020

 

7.      CRIM/APP. 23/17 - APPEAL

 

      BONGANI BAVUKILE DLAMINI

       AND

      REX

 

XABA ATTORNEYS                                            DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 4 MARCH 2020

 

8.      CIV/APP. 49/19 – APPEAL

 

          SISANA FAKUDZE & 2 OTHERS               

          AND

          TIKANE INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

 

M.H. MDLULI ATTORNEYS        KHUMALO NGCAMPHALALA

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 5 MARCH 2020

 

9.      CIV/APP.31/19 – APPEAL

 

          SWAZILAND COMPETITITION COMMISSION

          AND

          SWAZI MTN LTD

 

C.J. LITTLER & COMPANY              MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE

                                                                 ATTORNEYS

 

MONDAY 9 MARCH 2020

 

10.    CIV/APP. 64/19- APPEAL

 

          JM BUSHA CAPITAL SWAZILAND

          AND

          FINANCIAL SERVICES REGULATION AUTHORITY

 

S.V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES               ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 10 MARCH 2020

 

11.    CIV/APP. 47/19 – APPEAL

 

          SIBONGISENI KHUMALO

          AND

          COMMISSIONER OF POLICE & ANOTHER

 

BEN J. SIMELANE & ASSOCIATES     ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

WEDNESDAY 11 MARCH 2020

 

12.    CIV/APP. 78/13 – REVIEW

 

          SIMON VILANE & ANOTHER

 

          AND

 

          LIPNEY INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD & 6 OTHERS

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                                     C. J. LITTLER AND

                                                                                  ASSOCIATES

 

THURSDAY 12 MARCH 2020

 

13.    CIV/APP. 02/20 – APPEAL

 

        CHIEF ZWIDE NXUMALO & ANOTHER

        AND

        BERNARD NXUMALO & 2 OTHERS

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL                         HENWOOD & COMPANY

 

 

MONDAY 16 MARCH 2020

 

14.    CIV/APP. 41/19 – APPEAL

 

          MBABANE KOMBI AND MID BUS ASSOCIATION

          AND

          JABULANI MBUSO GULWAKO

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                   M. H. MDLULI ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 17 MARCH 2020

 

15.    CIV/APP. 17/19 – LEAVE TO APPEAL

 

       BROOKLYN INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

       AND

       BONGANI BHEMBE

 

MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS    MANYATSI AND

                                                                               ASSOCIATES

          .

WEDNESDAY 18 MARCH 2020

 

16.    CIV/APP. 35/19 –APPEAL

         

         JABULANI MANANA

          AND

          SWAZILAND BUILDING SOCIETY

 

L.R. MAMBA & ASSOCIATES                   ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 19 MARCH 2020

 

17.    CIV/APP. 51/19 – APPEAL

 

          SUKATI DUDU TAKHONA

          AND

          MING-CHANG GHIU

 

S.V. MDLADLA & ASS                                  WARING ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 23 MARCH 2020

 

18.    CIV/APP. 43/19 – APPEAL

 

          GCEBILE MABUZA

          AND

          REGISTRAR OF INSURANCE AND RETIREMENT FUND

 

MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS                           MKHWANAZI

                                                                                      ATTORNEYS

                                                               

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 24 MARCH 2020

 

 

19.    CIV/APP. 65/19 – APPEAL

 

          FIDELITY SECURITY SERVICES (PTY) LTD

          AND

          VICTOR MATSENJWA & ANOTHER

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATT.        ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

WEDNESDAY 25 MARCH 2020

 

 

20.    CIV/APP. 62/19 – LEAVE TO APPEAL

 

          JOHAN JACOB RUDOLPH & ANOTHER

          AND

          KANHYM ESTATES (PTY) LTD & 2 OTHERS

 

CURRIE-WRIGHT ASS.                                 ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 26 MARCH 2020

 

21.    CIV/APP. 56/19 – APPEAL

 

          DR BUTARE RUKUNDO & ANOTHER

          AND

          NANDI BUSISIWE FUPHE N.O. & 2 OTHERS

 

HENWOOD & COMPANY                         MAGAGULA & HLOPHE

                                                                ATTORNEYS

 

MONDAY 06 APRIL 2020

 

22.    CIV/APP. 60/19 – APPEAL

 

          THANDI L. DLAMINI

          AND

          REGINA T. DLAMINI & 4 OTHERS

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                     BS DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES

ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

TUESDAY 07 APRIL 2020

 

23.    CIV/APP. 73/19 – APPEAL

 

          SIYEMBILI MOTORS SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

          AND

          SWAZILAND COMPETITION COMMISSION

 

HENWOOD AND CO.                                      SIMELANE MTSHALI

                                                                          ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 08 APRIL 2020

 

24.    CIV/APP. 61/19 – APPEAL

 

          TEACHING SERVICE COMMISSION

          AND

          TIMOTHY TSABEDZE

 

          ATTORNEY GENERAL                MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                                            ATTORNEYS  

 

 

THURSDAY 09 APRIL 2020

 

25.    CIV/APP. 3/19 – REINSTATEMENT

 

          SIKHATSI DLAMINI

          AND

          THE MAYOR – MBABANE AND 9 OTHERS

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                       T.R. MASEKO ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 14 APRIL 2020

 

 

26.    CIV/APP. 97/16  – REINSTATEMENT

 

          JACOB YENDE

          AND

          NGONINI ESTATE (A DIVISION OF UNITED    PLANTATIONS) SWAZILAND LIMITED

 

MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS                  HENWOOD &

                                                                                         COMPANY

 

 

WEDNESDAY 15 APRIL 2020

 

27.    CIV/APP. 70/19 – LEAVE TO APPEAL

 

          SAMKELISIWE DLAMINI

          AND

          SIKHUMBUZO DLAMINI

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS            BS DLAMINI  

                                                                                            & ASSOCIATES

 

THURSDAY 16 APRIL 2020

 

28.    CIV/APP. 37/19 –  LEAVE TO APPEAL

 

          LOBUSUKU MASUKU & OTHERS

          AND

          NELISIWE ZANELE DE SOUSA & OTHERS

 

KHUMALO ATTORNEYS           HLABANGANE & ASSOCIATES

                                                             ATTORNEY GENERAL

                                                             ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                             S V MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES

 

MONDAY 20 APRIL 2020

 

29.    CIV/APP. 63/15 – REINSTATEMENT

 

          THE CHAIRPERSON OF KWALUSENI COUNCIL N.O.

          AND

          MUSA MOSES ZWANE & ANOTHER

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL                              NZIMA & ASSOCIATES

 

 

TUESDAY 21 APRIL 2020

 

30.    CIV/APP. 6/18 – REINSTATEMENT

 

          LOWVELD TRUCKING (PTY) LTD

          AND

          SWAZILAND RAILWAY

 

MABILA ATTORNEYS                                 ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 22 APRIL 2020

 

31.    CIV/APP.80/17 – REINSTATEMENT  

 

          THE CHAIRPERSON OF THE LIQUOR

           LICENSING BOARD & ANOTHER

           AND

          THULANI RUDOLPH MASEKO

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL                     T. R MASEKO ATTORNEYS

 

 

THURSDAY 23 APRIL 2020

 

32.    CIV/APP. 50/19 - ABANDONMENT

 

           PHETSILE NDZABANDZABA

           AND

          GABRIEL GODINHO & 2 OTHERS

 

S. M. JELE ATTORNEYS                 T. M. BHEMBE ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 04 MAY 2020

 

33.  CIV/APP. 18/19 - APPEAL

 

          MOSES SHONGWE

          AND

         MESHACK DLAMINI

 

  T.L DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES               ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

TUESDAY 05 MAY 2020

 

34.  CIV/APP. 69/19 – EXTENSION OF TIME

 

       PHINDUVUKE BUS SERVICE

       AND

      SIFISO MAMBA

 

ZONKE MAGAGULA & CO                     S. M JELE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 6 MAY 2020

 

35.  CIV/APP. 84/19 – APPEAL

 

        SWAZILAND REFORMED CHURCH, HHOHHO

        AND

        BHEKI MABENA

 

NTSHANGASE ATTORNEYS                    ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

THURSDAY 07 MAY 2020

 

36.    CIV/APP. 28/17 – REINSTATEMENT

 

          ATTORNEY GENERAL

          AND

          SIFISO SIBANDZE

 

ATTORNEY GENERAL                           MLK NDLANGAMANDLA

                                                                   ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

37.    CIV/APP. 65/16 – APPEAL

 

          SANDILE THWALA N.O & OTHERS

          AND

          MESHACK DLAMINI

 

HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS             MAGAGULA ATTORNEY GENERAL                                                   & HLOPHE DUNSEITH ATTORNEYS                                         ATTORNEYS

ROBINSON BERTRAM ATTORNEYS

                                                                                               

 

MONDAY 11 MAY 2020

 

38.    CIV/APP. 6/19 – APPEAL

 

          SIKHUMBUZO DLAMINI

          AND

          SAMUKELISIWE DLAMINI & 2 OTHERS

 

B.S. DLAMINI  AND ASSOCIATES           MAGAGULA & 

                                                                        HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

TUESDAY 12 MAY 2020

 

39.    CIV/APP. 22/19 – APPEAL

 

          FLETCHER ELECTRICAL (PTY) LTD

          AND

          ELIAS MABUZA & 2 OTHERS

 

M.H. MDLULI ATTORNEYS                         SIMELANE MTSHALI

                                                                           ATTORNEYS

 

WEDNESDAY 13 MAY 2020

 

40. CIV/APP. 13/18 - REINSTATEMENT/ COUNTER-APPEAL

      

        THE SWAZI OBSERVER NEWSPAPER (PTY) LTD

         t/a OBSERVER ON SATURDAY & TWO OTHERS

        AND

        DR. JOHANNES FUTHI DLAMINI

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS          ROBINSON

                                                                                       BERTRAM               

 

THURSDAY 14 MAY 2020

 

41.    CRIM/APP. 19/18 – APPEAL

 

          CHARLES JELE

          AND

          REX

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                                          DPP’S CHAMBERS

 

 

MONDAY 18 MAY 2020

 

42.    CRIM/APP. 22/18 – APPEAL

 

          THOKOZILE LINDIWE VILAKATI

          AND

          REX

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                                      DPP’S CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 19 MAY 2020

 

43.    CRIM/APP. 36/14 – REVIEW

 

          MFANASIBILI C DLAMINI

           AND

          REX

 

S A NKOSI ATTORNEY                                        DPP’S CHAMBERS

 

 

44. CIV/APP.25/19- APPEAL

 

      THE WOMAN AND CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL & ANOTHER

      AND

     THERESA-MARIE EARNSHAW ZEEMAN

 

L.R MAMBA & ASSOCIATES       RODRIGUES AND                                                                                             ASSOCIATES

      

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 20 MAY 2020

 

45.    CRIM/APP. 20/17 – REVIEW

 

           MUZI BONGANI SIKHONDZE

          AND

          REX

 

     LINDA DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES             DPP’S CHAMBERS

 

 

THURSDAY 21 MAY 2020

 

46.    CIV/APP. 36/16 – REVIEW

 

          SWAZILAND ELECTRICITY COMPANY

          AND

          GIDEON GWEBU & ANOTHER

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS      MLANGENI &                                                                                COMPANY

                                                                                    ROBINSON

                                                                                    BERTRAM

                                                                               

MONDAY 25 MAY 2020

 

47.    CIV/APP. 53/19 – REVIEW

 

          TUNTEX TEXTILE (PTY) LTD & ANOTHER

          AND

          ESWATINI GOVERNMENT & ANOTHER

 

HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATT. ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

TUESDAY 26 MAY 2020

 

48.    CIV/APP. 54/19 – REVIEW

 

          TONY COSTER & ANOTHER

          AND

          AFRICAN OXYGEN LIMITED

 

MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS                           HENWOOD &

                                                                                          COMPANY

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 27 MAY 2020

 

49.    CIV/ APP. 40/19 – APPEAL

 

          FLORENCE SIBONGILE BHEMBE

          AND

          MINAH SIMELANE

 

PROFESSOR M. DLAMINI                        ELVIS M. MAZIYA

ATTORNEYS

 

 

THURSDAY 28 MAY 2020

 

50.    CIV / APP. 66/ 19 – LEAVE TO APPEAL

 

          KUKHANYA (PTY) LTD t/a KUKHANYA CIVIL         ENGINEERING CONTRACTORS

AND

ABACUS CONSTRUCTION COST CONSULTANT

 

ROBINSON BERTRAM                                S. V. MDLADLA & ASSOCIATES

 

MONDAY 01 JUNE 2020

 

51.    CIV / APP. 35/ 17 – REINSTATEMENT

  

          UNION SUPPLIES (PTY) LTD

AND

PHANGOTHI INVESTMENT (PTY) LTD

 

L.R. MAMBA & ASSOCIATES

 

 

TUESDAY 02ND JUNE 2020

 

52.    CRIM / APP. 04/19 – APPEAL

         

          SANDILE MKHWANAZI

          AND

          REX

 

SB MOTSA ATTORNEYS                            DPP’s CHAMBERS

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 03RD JUNE 2020

 

53.  CIV APP. 58/19 - REVIEW

    

       TSWELOKGOTSO HEALTH (PTY) LTD

        AND

        RIVI (PTY) LTD & FOUR OTHERS

 

MUSA M SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS       WARING ATTORNEYS

 

THURSDAY 04TH JUNE 2020

 

54.    CIV/APP. 07/18 - REVIEW

 

          THE SWAZI OBSERVER (PTY) LTD t/a

          OBSERVER ON SATURDAY & 2 OTHERS

          AND

          ALPHEOUS NXUMALO

 

MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS        MAGAGULA & HLOPHE                                                                  ATTORNEYS

 

 

FRIDAY 05TH JUNE 2020

 

55.  CIV/APP. 18/18 - REVIEW

   

       SWAZILAND PERISHABLE FOODS (PTY) LTD

       t/a FOOD LOVERS MARKET & 3 OTHERS

       AND

       SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION

 

MAGAGULA & HLOPHE ATTORNEYS                       ROBINSON                                                                                                          BERTRAM