Supreme Court 2019 First Session Final Roll

Court: 
Supreme Court
Date: 
08 January 2019

                                                       

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF THE KINGDOM OF

                         ESWATINI

 

     FIRST SESSION COURT ROLL - 2019

                        FINAL

 

TO : Honourable Chief Justice

 

      Honourable Justices of the Supreme Court

 

      Honourable Justices of the High Court

 

      Honourable Justices of the Industrial Court

 

      Attorney General

 

      The Director of Public Prosecutions

 

      The Registrar of the High Court

 

      The Registrar of the Industrial Court

 

      The National  Commissioner of Police

 

      The Commissioner General of Correctional Services

 

      The Law Society of ESwatini

 

      Litigants In Person

CIVIL AND CRIMINAL CASES

 

 

MONDAY 11 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

 

  1. CIV/APP.29/18- APPEAL

 

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL                                

 

  1.  

 

     HOWARD P. NKAMBULE

   

                                                                               

     ATTORNEY GENERAL                RODRIGUES AND ASSOCIATES

 

 

 

  1.  CIV/APP. 96/18- APPEAL

 

      FLOYD MKHATSHWA AND ANOTHER

 

               AND

 

      CHAIRMAN ELECTION AND BOUNDARIES COMMISSION

      AND TWO OTHERS

 

    DLAMINI KUNENE ASSOCIATED            PILISO SIMELANE AND

                                                               PARTNERS

  •  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

TUESDAY 12 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

  1. CIV/APP.01/17

                      

       

    SWAZI AUCTIONEERS (PTY) LIMITED AND OTHERS

 

                 AND

 

   SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT AND SAVINGS BANK

 

   L.R. MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES.     MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE

                                                         ATTORNEYS     

 

 

  1. CIV/APP.84/18

 

     MATATA RETAIL (PTY) LIMITED

 

           AND

 

      VIVA BEVERAGES (PTY) LIMITED

 

 

      ROBINSON BETRAM                             WARING ATTORNEYS.

 

                                                                                             WEDNESDAY 13 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

  1. CIV/APP.73/18

                               

           AFRICAN OXYGEN LIMITED

 

                  AND                              

            

           TONY COSTER AND ANOTHER

 

       HENWOOD AND COMPANY               MUSA M SIBANDZE

                                                               ATTORNEYS

                                                                 

                                                

 

  1. CIV /APP. 90/18

 

         JOYCE BHEKEPHI DLAMINI

 

                  AND

 

          BONGANI PHINDA DLAMINI & OTHERS

 

          B.S. DLAMINI & ASSOCIATES.                    TR MASEKO

                                                                            ATTORNEYS.

 

 

       THURSDAY 14 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

  1. CIV/APP. 53/18

                           

           PHANGOTHI INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

                      AND

                         

           TAGA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD  

 

           SITHOLE & MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS    HENWOOD &

                                                                         COMPANY.

 

         8. CIV/APP. 56/18

 

UNIFOODS (PTY) LTD

 

  1.  

 

MARK DLAMINI AND OTHERS

 

           B.S. DLAMINI AND ASSOCIATES.            MALINGA AND

  1.  
  2.  

 

 

  MONDAY 18 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

9. CIV/APP. 83/18

 

          SWAZILAND REVENUE AUTHORITY & OTHERS

       

               AND

       

   PRESIDING JUDGES OF THE INDUSTRIAL COURT OF

   APPEAL & OTHERS

                                                       

           ROBINSON BERTRAM         SITHOLE & MAGAGULA

                                                     ATTORNEYS.

                                                        ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

      TUESDAY 19 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

  1. CIV/ APP. 39/18

 

                BUYISILE MAVIMBELA & OTHERS

       

                        AND

                                   

                 HAPPY COLISILE MAVIMBELA

 

               SITHOLE & MAGAGULA ATTORNYES.   ROBINSON

                                                                            BERTRAM

 

 

 

  1. CIV/APP. 102/18

 

           THE PUB & GRILL (PTY) LTD AND ANOTHER

 

                       AND

 

           THE GABLES

 

           MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS        WARING

                                                                               ATTORNEYS

 

 

    WEDNESDAY 20 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

  1. CRIM/APP. 22/18

 

           DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

 

                   AND

 

           SIPHO SHONGWE

 

           DPP                       S.S. MNISI ATTORNEY

 

 

     THURSDAY 21 FEBRUARY 2019

 

 

13.   CIV/APP. 50/18

                                                                                                                                                          

        DUPS HOLDINGS (PTY) LTD & OTHERS

 

                AND

 

        WALTER BENNET & OTHERS

 

        NKOMONDZE ATTORNEYS.     MAKHOSI C. VILAKATI

                                                       ATTORNEYS.

 

  1. CRIM/APP. 31/17

 

             BANELE MAMBA

 

                   AND

 

               REX

 

             MABILA ATTORNEYS                             DPP

 

 

   MONDAY 4 MARCH 2019

 

 

15.  CIV/APP. 25/18

 

       SWAZILAND ELECTRICITY CO.

 

                    AND

 

        GIDEON GWEBU

                                                                       

       MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS     MLANGENI &

                                                                        COMPANY

                                                                            ROBINSON

                                                                         BERTRAM

 

 

16. CIV/APP. 95/18

                                                                                                                                       

      BHEKI ALEX KHUMALO                                             

 

                     AND

 

      BALENI INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

 CJ LITTLER & COMPANY.             MTM NDLOVU

                                                            ATTORNEYS.

 

TUESDAY 5 MARCH 2019

 

 

17.     CIV/APP. 28/18

 

            HAMILTON S. DLAMINI

 

                AND

 

            EUNICE MBHAMALI & OTHERS

 

            BEN J. SIMELANE & ASSOCIATES.   SP MAMBA

                                                                    ATTORNEYS

 

18.   CIV/APP. 34/17

 

 

        LIKIMA MNJOLI ROYAL KRAAL (INNER COUNCIL)

 

                         AND

 

         MKHAMO ABRAHAM MAGAGULA & 5 OTHERS

 

         KUSH VILAKATI & ASSOCIATES.   ATTORNEY GENERAL

                                                               IN PERSON

 

WEDNESDAY 6 MARCH 2019

 

 

19. CIV/APP. 68/17

 

      DOCTOR HLATJWAKO

 

            AND

 

       DOUGLAS LUSHABA AND OTHERS

 

      N.E GININDZA ATTORNEYS.            IN PERSON

 

                                                             ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

   20. CIV/APP. 71/18

 

         INTER AGENCIES (PTY) LTD

 

                AND

 

        CORBAN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONICS (PTY) LTD AND

        OTHERS.

 

      MANYATSI AND ASSOCIATES.        GIGI A.  REID ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 07 MARCH 2019

 

21.   CIV/APP. 56/13

 

         NICHOLAS MANANA AND OTHERS

 

                  AND

 

          ACTING PRESIDENT OF THE INDUSTRIAL COURT AND

          OTHERS

 

           M. HLOPHE AND ASSOCIATES.          ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                                 ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

 

 

   

  MONDAY 11 MARCH 2019

 

 

22. CIV/APP. 21/18

 

       NGWANE MILLS (PTY) LTD

 

                AND

 

       SWAZILAND REVENUE AUTHORITY AND ANOTHER

 

       ROBINSON BERTRAM        S.V. MDLADLA AND ASSOCIATES.

 

 

 

 

23. CIV/APP.24/18

 

       THANDIWE NKAMBULE

 

               AND

 

         MPHIKELELI MAMBA

 

 

       ZONKE MAGAGULA AND COMPANY    L.R. MAMBA AND

                                                                 ASSOCIATES

 

                                          

 TUESDAY 12 MARCH 2019

 

                                                               

24. CIV/APP. 76/18

 

      SANDRA KHUMALO AND OTHERS

 

               AND

 

       LOMDASHI LIMITED

 

        BHEMBE ATTORNEYS.                    MADZINANE ATTORNEYS.

 

 

25. CIV/APP. 36/18

 

       SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE

       CORPORATION

 

              AND

 

       SIBONGILE CLARA NDLANGAMANDLA

        T/A BAYANDZA PRE AND PRIMARY SCHOOL

        AND ANOTHER

 

        ROBINSON BERTRAM                              IN PERSON

 

 

WEDNESDAY 13 MARCH 2019

 

 

26. CIV APP.41/18

 

      THE QUADRO TRUST AND OTHERS

 

             AND

 

       PAUL MABUZA N.O.

 

       L.R. MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES.          BHEMBE ATTORNEYS.

 

 

27. CIV/APP. 72/17

 

       SAGILA DLAMINI

 

             AND

 

        DIESEL SERVICES (PTY) LTD AND ANOTHER

 

 

        V.Z. DLAMIN ATTORNEYS               FAKUDZE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

THURSDAY 14 MARCH 2019          

 

 

28. CIV/APP. 48/18

 

     HUNTER SHONGWE

 

           AND

 

    PRISCILLA DLAMINI AND OTHERS

 

   ROBINSON BERTRAM         MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE

                                             ATTORNEYS.

 

 

29. CIV/APP. 97/16

 

    JACOB C. YENDE

 

          AND

 

    NGONINI ESTATE (A DIVISION OF UNITED PLANTATIONS)

    SWAZILAND LIMITED

 

     MLK NDLANGAMANDLA ATTORNEYS      HENWOOD AND

                                                                   COMPANY

 

 

 

 

 

 

     MONDAY 18 MARCH 2019

 

 

30. CIV/APP. 68/18                                                                                                                                        

   

       FOOT THE BILL INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

              AND

 

       XOLILE GAMA AND OTHERS

 

 

        HENWOOD AND COMPANY.             MABILA ATTORNEYS

 

 

31. CIV/APP. 91/18

 

       MONGI JELE AND 20 OTHERS

 

             AND

 

        CHIEF NKAMANE MKHATSHWA AND ANOTHER

 

        L.R MAMBA AND ASSOCIATES        ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

TUESDAY/WEDNESDAY 19/20 MARCH 2019

 

 

32. CIV/APP. 73/16

 

  THE PRIME MINISTER OF ESWATINI AND OTHERS

 

                   AND

 

       THULANI MASEKO AND OTHERS

 

 

        ATTORNEY GENERAL        T.R MASEKO ATTORNEYS

MONDAY 01 APRIL 2019

 

 

33. CIV APP. 18/18

 

 

      SWAZILAND PERISHABLE FOODS (PTY) LTD

      T/A FOOD LOVERS MARKET AND OTHERS

 

                AND

 

      SWAZILAND DEVELOPMNET FINANCE CORPORATION

 

 

       HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS.       ROBINSON

                                                                            BERTRAM

34. CIV APP. 69/18

 

      THANDI MOTSA AND 4 OTHERS

 

               AND

 

       RICHARD KHANYILE

 

       NZIMA AND ASSOCIATES.             ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

TUESDAY 02 APRIL 2019

 

35. CIV/APP. 28/17

 

      ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

           AND

 

       SIFISO SIBANDZE

 

 

 

       ATTORNEY GENERAL              MLK NDLANGAMANDLA

                                                       ATTORNEYS.

 

 

    WEDNESDAY 03 APRIL 2019

 

 

36. CIV/APP. 65/18

 

      CYNTHIA MPHO DLAMINI (BORN SIMELANE)

 

             AND

 

       CLEOPAS SIPHO DLAMIN

 

       SIMELANE MTSHALI ATTORNEYS       L. R. MAMBA AND

                                                                  ASSOCIATES.

 

 

 

37. CIV/APP. 63/18

 

       BOKIES CONSTRUCTION AND CIVIL (PTY) LTD

       AND OTHERS

 

                  AND

 

       NEDBANK SWAZILAND

 

 

  MAGAGULA ATTORNEYS.    S.V. MDLADLA AND ASSOCIATES.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 THURSDAY 04 APRIL 2019

 

 

38. CIV APP. 96/17

 

 

      MINSTER OF TOURISM AND ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS

      AND ANOTHER

 

                   AND

 

      STEVEN ZUKE AND ANOTHER

 

      ROBINSON BETRAM           ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

MONDAY 08 APRIL 2019

 

                                                                      

39. CIV/APP. 69/17

 

      SWAZILAND NATIONAL HOUSING BOARD

 

                  AND

 

        THANDEKA DLAMINI

 

        HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS           MTM NDLOVU

                                                                             ATTORNEYS

 

TUESDAY 09 APRIL 2019

 

 

40. CRIM/APP. 20/14

 

       DUMSANI TREVOR DLAMINI

 

                 AND

 

                 REX

 

       S.B. MOTSA ATTORNEYS                           DPP

 

 

WEDNESDAY 10 APRIL 2019

 

 

41. CIV APP.42/18

 

       ALAN ALEXANDER McGREGOR

 

              AND

 

       ROBERT CRABTREE AND OTHERS

 

       MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS.      MAKHOSI C.

                                                                          VILAKATI

                                                                          ATTORNEYS

 

 

42. CRIM/APP. 07/16

 

       BOY MCHUMANISI MKHATSHWA

 

               AND

 

               REX

 

 

        S.B. MOTSA ATTORNEYS                             DPP

 

 

 

                                 

 

 

 

THURSDAY 11 APRIL 2019

 

 

43. CIV/APP. 106/17

 

       MANGALISO DLAMINI

 

              AND

 

       SIKHATSI DLAMINI N. O.

 

       BHEMBE ATTORNEYS.                               IN PERSON

 

 

44. CRIM/APP. 22/17

 

       DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

 

                     AND

 

       STANLEY NHLAKALUFU AND OTHERS

 

       BEN J. SIMELANE AND ASSOCIATES        DPP

 

 

MONDAY 15 APRIL 2019

 

 

45. CIV/APP. 58/16

 

      MICHEAL MASOTJA SHONGWE

 

              AND

 

        HENRY SIBUSISO SHONGWE N.O.

 

        C.J. LITTLER AND COMPANY        BHEMBE ATTORNEYS

 

 

TUESDAY 16 APRIL 2019

 

 

46. CIV/APP. 79/17

 

      RUBBERTECH SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD

 

                            AND

  

       SWAZILAND NATIONAL PROVIDENT FUND BOARD

 

 

       MUSA M. SIBANDZE ATTORNEYS.              WARING

                                                                         ATTORNEYS.

 

47. CRIM/APP. 20/18

 

       MZWANDILE KHETHABAKHE SIYAYA

 

                      AND

 

                      REX

 

       DLAMINI KUNENE ASSOCIATED                         DPP

 

 

WEDNESDAY 17 APRIL 2019

 

                                                                   

48. CIV/APP. 13/18

 

       THE SWAZI OBSERVER NEWSPAPER AND OTHERS

 

                 AND

 

        DR JOHANNES FUTHI DLAMINI

 

        MAGAGULA AND HLOPHE ATTORNEYS.          ROBINSON

                                                                               BERTRAM

 

THURSDAY 18 APRIL 2019

 

 

49. CIV/APP. 37/18

 

     MUSA GOODMAN DLAMINI

 

             AND

 

     NOMPHUMELELO DLAMINI (BORN NXUMALO)

 

 

     ZONKE MAGAGULA AND COMPANY     KHUMALO

                                                               NGCAMPHALALA

                                                               ATTORNEYS

 

 

50. CIV/APP. 08/16

 

      SIMANGA GINA

 

         AND

 

      CLEMENT SIMELANE

 

      S.V. MDLADLA AND ASSOCIATES     SITHOLE MAGAGULA

                                                              ATTORNEYS

 

 

MONDAY 06 MAY 2019

 

51. CIV/ APP. 80/17

 

       THE CHAIRMAN, LIQUOR LICENSING BOARD

 

                AND

 

        THULANI MASEKO

 

       ATTORNEY GENERAL       T.R. MASEKO ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

52. CIV/APP. 67/17&70/18 CONSOLIDATED

 

        BARAKA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

 

              AND

 

        DARYALI INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD/

 

        MKHULULI DLAMINI

  

               AND

 

         DARYALI INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD AND OTHERS

 

 

         NKOMONDZE ATTORNEYS.            S.V. MDLADLA AND

                                                              ASSOCIATES

 

TUESDAY 07 MAY 2019

 

 

53. CIV/APP. 14/18

 

 

       RECON TRANSPORTATION SOLUTIONS (PTY) LTD

 

                      AND

 

       SWAZISPA HOLDINGS LIMITED

 

        SIMELANE MTSHALI ATTORNEYS.     HENWOOD AND

                                                                  COMPANY.

 

54. CIV/APP. 40/18

 

     GIDEON M. DLAMINI

 

            AND

 

     THE MINISTER OF FINANCE AND OTHERS

 

     MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS        ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

 

WEDNESDAY 08 MAY 2019

 

 

55. CIV/APP.  86/18

 

        TUNTEX TEXTILE (PTY) LTD AND ANOTHER

 

                   AND

 

        ESWATINI GOVERNMENT AND ANOTHER

 

      HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS.        ATTORNEY

                                                                             GENERAL

 

56. CIV/APP. 54/18

 

 

        PETER GEORGE AND ANOTHER

 

             AND

 

        MBUSO E. SIMELANE N.O

 

        HENWOOD AND COMPANY                 MBUSO E. SIMELANE

                                                                  ATTORNEYS.

 

 

 

 

     THURSDAY 09 MAY 2019

 

57. CRIM/APP. 15/17

 

        NKOSIVILE GOODWILL LUSHABA

 

              AND

 

              REX

 

      MABILA ATTORNEYS.                            DPP

 

 

58. CRIM/APP. 23/17

 

        BONGANI BAVUKILE DLAMINI

 

             AND

 

              REX

 

 

        IN PERSON                                          DPP

 

 

 

    MONDAY 13 MAY 2019

 

 

59. CRIM/APP.13/16

 

        THE COMMISSIONER OF THE ANTI-CORRUPTION

        COMMISSION

 

               AND

 

           GIDEON DLAMINI AND OTHERS

 

           DPP                                         MTM NDLOVU ATTORNEYS                                          

 

 

 

60. CRIM/APP. 16/18

 

       VIKA VELABO DLAMINI

 

                AND

 

                REX

 

       BHEMBE ATTORNEYS                             DPP

 

 

TUESDAY 14 MAY 2019

 

 

     

61. CIV/APP. 78/13

 

      SIMON VILANE N. O

 

            AND

 

       LIPNEY INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD AND OTHERS

 

       ROBINSON BERTRAM              M.E. SIMELANE ATTORNEYS

 

 

WEDNESDAY 15 MAY 2019

 

 

62. CIV/APP.100/17

 

      THE WEEKEND OBSERVER (PTY) LTD

 

                    AND

 

       SIPHO MAKHABANE

 

       MAGAGULA HLOPHE ATTORNEYS      ROBINSON BERTRAM

 

 

 

THURSDAY 16 MAY 2019

 

 

63. CIV/APP. 65/16

 

      SANDILE THWALA N.O. AND OTHERS

 

             AND

 

      MESHACK DLAMINI

 

      HOWE MASUKU NSIBANDE ATTORNEYS    MAGAGULA AND

                                                                HLOPHE ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

MONDAY 20 MAY 2019

 

 

64. CIV/APP.72/18

 

    GOVERNMENT OF SWAZILAND

 

           AND

 

     LUCKY MHLANGA AND TWO OTHERS

 

     ATTORNEY GENERAL                XABA ATTORNEYS

                                                      ROBINSON BERTRAM

                                                      MKHWANAZI ATTORNEYS

TUESDAY 21 MAY 2019

 

  1. CIV/APP.87/18- APPEAL

 

SIHLE DLAMINI AND ANOTHER

            

  1.  

 

SELINAH ZWANE-SIMELANE AND OTHERS

 

 

   ROBINSON BERTRAM                            THWALA ATTORNEYS

 

 

 

 

66. CIV/APP. 34/18- APPEAL

 

      CHIEF BENJAMIN AGHALIEAKU AND TWO OTHERS

 

                   AND

 

     ANTI-CORRUPTION COMMISSION AND ANOTHER

 

     ZONKE MAGAGULA AND COMPANY                   DPP

 

 

WEDNESDAY 22 MAY 2019

 

67. CIV/APP. 57/18- APPEAL

 

    FRANCISCA THANDEKA SHAYO

 

           AND

 

     LINAH THEMBI MBHAMALI N.O AND OTHERS

 

    ROBINSON BERTRAM                  S.M. KHOZA ATTORNEYS

 

                                                        ATTORNEY GENERAL

 

68. CIV/APP. 85/18

 

       ELLEN MAGAGULA

 

              AND

 

       THEMBA MAGAGULA AND OTHERS

 

    SIMELANE MTSHALI ATTORNEYS             WARING ATTORNEYS