Supreme Court Roll - 3 May 2016

Court: 
The Supreme Court
Date: 
03 May 2016

 

                                                         

 

THE SUPREME COURT OF SWAZILAND

 

MAY 2016 SESSION COURT ROLL

 

FINAL

         

 

 

TO:  Honourable Justices of Appeal

        Honourable Justices of the High Court

        Honourable Attorney General

        The Director of Public Prosecutions

        The Registrar of the High Court

        The Commissioner of Police

        The Commissioner of Correctional Services

        Their Worships the Magistrates

        The Law Society of Swaziland

        Legal Practitioners

        Litigants in Person.

 

NB: There will be a roll call on Tuesday 3rd May 2016 at 08.30 a.m.   All Legal Practitioners as well as litigants appearing in person are requested to attend the roll call.  Take further notice that no postponements will be entertained except for good cause shown on written application and properly motivated in open court. 

                            CRIMINAL AND CIVIL CASES

 

TUESDAY 3 MAY 2016  

 

COURT A

 

 

1.    C OF A (CIV) 77/2013

                                                                                     

       AFRICAN ECHO (PTY) LTD & 2 OTHERS                      

       V                                                                            

       INKHOSATANA GELANE SIMELANE                         

 

       ( Musa Sibandze Attorneys)   (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

 

 

2.     C OF A (CIV) 55/2014                            

                                                                          

        ATTORNEY GENERAL

        V                                                

        MASTER OF THE HIGH COURT

 

        (Attorney General’s Chambers/Master of the High Court)

 

 

 

COURT B

 

3.     C OF A (CIV) 22/2016                                    

                                                                              

        MPHETSENI CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD              

        V

        L.R. MAMBA & ASSOCIATES

 

        (Dunseith Attorneys) (L.R. Mamba & Associates)

 

 

 

 

 

4.     C OF A (CIV) 70/2014                                                 

                                                                                             

        IVAN GROENING                                                                                                 V                                                                      

        STEALTH SECURITY (PTY) LTD & 3 OTHERS

 

        (Rodrigues & Associates) (Nkomondze Attorneys)

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 4 MAY 2016

 

 

COURT A 

 

 

5.     C OF A (CIV) 84/2015                                

                                                                   

        SWAZILAND GOVERNMENT                                      

        V                                                                               

        SNACS ON BEHALF OF HOSPITAL ORDERLIES &

        AUXILIARY STAFF & 2 OTHERS                                                        

        (Attorney General’s Chambers) (Dunseith Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

6.     C OF A (CIV) 22/2014                                           

                                                                                     

        VMB INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD                                       

        V                                                                             

        BOYBOY NYEMBE & ANOTHER

 

        (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)    (M.P. Simelane Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

 

 

COURT B 

 

 

7.       C OF A (CIV) 17/2016                               

                                                                              

          BILAL INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD

          V

          G.S. TRADERS (PTY) LTD T/A LADIES & GENTS

          FASHION & 3 OTHERS

   

          (Masina Ndlovu Attorneys)    (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

 

 

8.      C OF A (CIV) 16/2015                                                    

                                                                                             

 SWAZILAND REVENUE AUTHORITY                                 

 V                                                                    

         MICHAEL M. RAMODIBEDI

       

         (S.V. Mdladla Attorneys)    (In person)

  

 

               

FRIDAY 6 MAY 2016

       

 

COURT A 

 

  9.   C OF A (CIV) 35/2013                                                    

                                                                                                 

        CHRISTOPHER VILAKATI                                     

        V

        THE PRIME MINISTER OF SWAZILAND

       

(Robinson Bertram Attorneys) (Attorney General’s Chambers)

 

 

 

 

10.    C OF A (CIV) 29/2015                                                

                                                                                           

         MBOMBO DLAMINI

         V      

         CHIEF HYND DLAMINI

 

         (T.L. Dlamini Attorneys)     (Attorney General’s Chambers)

 

 

COURT B

 

 

11.   C OF A (CIV) 12/2016                                   

                                                                               

         SKHUMBUZO DLAMINI                                                

         V                                                                                             

         THE QUADRO TRUST & 8 OTHER                                                                                

          (Bhembe Attorneys) (L.R. Mamba Attorneys)

         (Dunseith Attorneys)

 

 

12.    C OF A (CIV) 227/2015                                            

                                                   

JOSEPH SAMBO                                       

         V                                                                                                                  ALFRED MABANGA 

 

          (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys)  (Howe Masuku Nsibande Attorneys)

 

 

MONDAY 9 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

13.   C OF A (CIV) 06/2016                            

                                                                           

         IDAH HILL                                

          V

         SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION

& ANOTHER

        

         (Fakudze Attorneys)     (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)        

14.    C OF A (CIV) 09/2015

                                               

        NOMFUNDO NSIBANDZE

       V                                                                       

        THANDA MNGWENGWE & ANOTHER   

                       

        (N.E Ginindza Attorneys)    (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys)

 

 

COURT B

 

15.   C OF A (CIV) 81/2015                                                 

                                                                                           

        LEBOMBO TRADING (PTY) LTD                                               

        V                                                                             

        FHS ACCOUNTANCY & MANAGEMENT SERVICES (PTY) LTD        

       (Lloyd Mzizi Attorneys)  (Rodrigues & Associates)

                  

         

 

16.     C OF A (CIV) 30/2015                                                       

                                                                                           

          DE BARRY ANITA BELINDA

          V

          AG THOMAS (PTY) LTD

 

           (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys) (Waring Attorneys)

 

 

TUESDAY 10 MAY 2016

 

COURT A         

 

17.     C OF A (CIV) 34/2015                                                        

                                                                                                    

           THULANI RUDOLF MASEKO                                                 

           V

           HON. CHIEF JUSTICE & 5 OTHERS

 

          (Mkhwanazi Attorneys) (Attorney General’s Chambers)

18.   C OF A (CIV) 25/2016                                  

                                                                            

        CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION & 3 OTHERS                                  

        V                                                                                

        HLOBSILE NDZIMANDZE                                                                         

        (Attorney General’s Chambers) (Musa Sibandze Attorneys)

 

 

COURT B

 

 

19.   C OF A (CIV) 23/2016                                

                                                                             

        XOLILE SIHLONGONYANE T/A THE PROPERTY

        SHOP & ANOTHER                           

        V                                                                     

        JABULANI ELLIOT SIHLONGONYANE

 

        (Mabila & Associates) (Motsa Mavuso Attorneys)

 

 

 

20.     C OF A (CIV) 40/2015                                             

                                                                                            

          SYDNEY DLAMINI

          V

          SABELO SIMELANE

                                                                           

          (Nzima & Associates) (Madau Simelane Mtshali Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

WEDNESDAY 11 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

 

21.    C OF A (CIV) 45/2015                                                      

                                                                                          

        SIBONISO CLEMENT DLAMINI & ANOTHER                                       V                                                                                                        WALTER P. BENNET & 3 OTHERS   

             

        (S.C. Dlamini Attorneys)  (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys)

    

 

22.    C OF A (CRIM) 38/2002                                                    

                                                                                                

         RICHARD PHENI MABASO                                               

         V

         REX

 

        (Attorney Sabelo Bhembe- Pro-deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

 

COURT B

 

 

23.    C OF A (CIV) 47/2015                                                     

                                                                                                    

         TQM TEXTILES SWAZILAND (PTY) LTD                                                       V                                                                            

         SIFISO SIMELANE & 354 OTHERS                                                                   

        (MP Simelane Attorneys)     (Motsa Mavuso Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

 

 

24.   C OF A (CRIM) 02/2007                                                  

                                                                                                 

        THOKOZANI VILAKATI                                                                       V                                                                               

        REX

       

        (Attorney Leo Gama Pro-deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

 

 

THURSDAY 12 MAY 2016

 

 

COURT A

 

 

25.   C OF A (CIV) 48/2015

                                                                              

        BOY HLOPHE NO & 7 OTHERS            

V                                                                            

        DUMISA NDZIMANDZE NO & OTHERS                                                         

 

        (Sithole Magagula Attorneys) (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

26.  C OF A (CRIM) 06/2013                                                 

                                                                                           

       SANDILE HYND LUKHELE                                         

       V

       REX

 

       (In-Person)  (DPP’s Chambers) 

       (Rape)

 

 

 

 

COURT B

 

 

27.   C OF A (CIV) 51/2015                                           

                                                                                   

                TIMOTHY KHOZA

        V                                                             

        PIGGS PEAK TOWN COUNCIL & ANOTHER

 

        (TL Dlamini Attorneys)  (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

        (Lloyd Mzizi Attorneys)                                              

       

28.     C OF A (CRIM) 41/2012                                                                

                                                                                                          

          NTOKOZO MALINGA                                                                                                   

          V

          REX

 

          (Mabila Attorneys)  (DPP’s Chambers)

          (Murder)

 

 

 

FRIDAY 13 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

 

29.     C OF A (CIV) 59/2015 (B)

                                                                                     

          CENTRAL BANK OF SWAZILAND                                       

          V                                                                                             

          YAMTHANDA INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD  

 

          (MP Simelane Attorneys) (Sithole Magagula Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

 

30.   C OF A (CRIM) 27/2014                                   

                                                                               

                NHLANHLA MDAKA MOTSA                                                      

        V                                                                                              REX                                                                                                 

        (Attorney Wandile Maseko-Pro deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

COURT B

 

31.    C OF A (CIV) 15/2016

 

        THE REGIONAL ADMINISTRATOR AND 6 OTHERS

        V

        COSHIWE MATSENJWA AND SEVEN OTHERS

 

        (Attorney General’s Chambers) (Malinga & Malinga Company)

 

32.   C OF A (CRI) 17/2013                                                 

                                                                                    

         SPHAMANDLA HENSON DLAMINI                                                      V                                                                          

         REX                                                                        

 

         (Attorney Xolani Mthethwa-Pro deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

         (Murder)

 

 

MONDAY 16 MAY 2016

 

COURT A   

     

33.    C OF A (CIV) 61/2015                                                             

                                                                                                        

         FIRST FINANCE (PTY) LTD                           

         V

         BHEKINKOSI BRIGHT TSABENDZE

 

        (Robinson Bertram Attorneys) (In Person)

 

34.    C OF A (CRIM) 19/2015                                                    

                                                                                                 

        WILLIAM VALINDZAWO NDLANDLA                                             

        V

        REX

 

        (Attorney Lucky Howe- Pro deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

 

 

COURT B         

 

 

35.   C OF A (CIV) 65/2015                                                           

                                                                                                       

        PIET ZACHARIAS EBERSOHN NO                                              

        V                                                                             

        SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT & SAVINGS BANK & ANOTHER             

        (Motsa Mavuso Attorneys)  (S.V. Mdladla Attorneys)

        (Mbuso Simelane & Associates)

 

 

 

 

36.    C OF A (CRIM) 35/2014                                              

                                                                                            

         SIBONISO CASPER MASUKU                            

         V                                                                            

         REX                                                                

       

         (Fakudze Attorneys)  (DPP’s Chambers)

         (Murder)

 

                         

                     

 

 

TUESDAY 17 MAY 2016

 

COURT A   

 

 

37.   C OF A (CIV) 71/2015                                                          

                                                                                                      

        JIMSON JEKE TFWALA                                                                     V                                                                              

        SWAZILAND DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION                  

 

       (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys) (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

 

 

 

38.    C OF A (CRIM) 30/2015                                                 

                                                                                             

         THANDAZA NKOSIKAYIBEKWA SILOLO                                                       

         V           

         REX

 

        (In-Person)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Terrorism)

 

 

 

COURT B

 

         

39.    C OF A (CIV) 67/2015

                                                                                               

         MBUSO E. SIMELANE NO                                 

         V                                                                                     

         BARBARA PROMISE LITTLER NO & 2 OTHERS                                                        

                                                                         

        (Mbuso Simelane & Ass ) (Howe Masuku Sibande Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

40.   C OF A (CRIM) 37/2014                                                      

                                                                                                  

        MCOLISI SICELO DLAMINI                                        

        V

        REX

 

        (Attorney Sabelo Masuku- Pro deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

 

 

WENSDAY 18 MAY 2016

 

 COURT A  

 

 

41.    C OF A (CIV) 74/2015

        

         NKONYENI FARMS (PTY) LTD

         V

         SWAZILAND INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANY & 3 OTHE                                                          

                                                                                                

         (J M Currie Attorneys) (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys) 

         (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

 

 

 

42.    C OF A (CRIM) 8 & 10/2016                                               

                                                                                            

         FANA JOEL MASILELA AND ANOTHER                                      

         V

         REX

 

        (Mabila Attorneys)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

 

 

 

 

COURT B  

      

 

43.   C OF A (CIV) 68/2015

                                                      

        MP SIMELANE ATTORNEYS                                                                                           

        V

        BEAUTY BUILD CONSTRUCTIONS (PTY) LTD                                     

        (Mabila Attorneys) (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)

         

 

 

THURSDAY 19 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

 

44.   C OF A (CRIM) 27/2015

 

        ZANELE DLAMINI & ANOTHER

        V

        REX

 

        (Attorney Thulani Sibandze Pro-Deo) (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Murder)

 

 

 

45.   C OF A (CIV) 77/2015                                                                                                                                                               

        DAVIDSON DISTRIBUTION (PTY) LTD                                               

        V

SWAZILAND COMPETITION COMMISSION           

 

        (Magagula Attorneys) (CJ Littler & Company)

 

 

 

 

 

46.   C OF A (CRIM) 28/2013                                               

                                                                                            

        MPUMELELO MAMBA & 2 OTHER                                           

        V

        REX

 

        (B.S. Dlamini Attorneys)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Theft)

 

 

COURT B        

 

 

47.    C OF A (CIV) 72/2015                                                       

                                                                                                  

         MAJAZI INVESTMENTS (PTY) LTD                                 

         V

         SWAZILAND BUILDING SOCIETY

 

        (L.R. Mamba Attorneys) (S.V. Mdladla Attorneys)

 

 

 48.   C OF A (CRIM) 30/2014                                               

                                                                                            

        THULI MKHONTA                                                    

        V

        REX

 

        (Leo Gama & Associates)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Fraud)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

FRIDAY 20 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

 

49.    C OF A (CIV) 80/2015                                             

                                                                                        

         MPHIKELELI MAMBA                                    

         V                                                                           

         U.S.A. DISTILLERS & ANOTHER

 

         (L.R Mamba & Associates)    (Zonke Magagula Attorneys)      

      

 

 

50.    C OF A (CRIM) 03 /2016                                                 

                                                                                             

        MUSA WAGA KUNENE                                              

        V                                                                             

REX                                         

 

        (Mabila Attorneys)  (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Bail)

 

 

COURT B

         

 

 51.   C OF A (CIV) 75/2015                                                          

                                                                                                     

         ZULU INVESTMENT (SWAZILAND) (PTY) LTD T/A SWANKS                                           

         V                                                                        

 PLAZA PARK (PTY) LTD

 

        (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys) (Boxshall-Smith Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

 

 

52.  C OF A (CRIM) 36/2014                                                   

                                                                                            

       MFANASIBILI CHARLES DLAMINI                        

       V

       REX

 

       (Attorney Sibonelo Dlamini-Pro deo)  (DPP’s Chambers)

       (Murder)

 

 

 

MONDAY 23 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

 

53.    C OF A (CIV) 82/2015                                            

                                                                                    

SEYLAN TRAVEL & TOURS (PTY) LTD T/A UNIGLOBE SEY TRAVEL

        V                                                             

        QUALITY CATERING SERVICES (PTY) LTD

 

        (Attorney Elvis M. Maziya) (Gigi A.Reid Attorneys)

 

         

 

54.   C OF A (CRIM) 23/2015

 

        GEORGE DANIEL MATHONSI & OTHERS

        V

        REX

       

        (Attorney Fayiya Tenbehg-Pro deo)  (DPP’s Chambers) 

        (Murder)

 

 

 

 

COURT B     

   

 

55.     C OF A (CIV) 79/2015

                                                                                        

          BUSINESS 100 & PICTURE FRAMES & ANOTHER                

          V                                                                   

          DICKSON MASEKO

 

          (In Person)  (Madau Simelane Attorneys)  

      

56.   C OF A (CRIM) 33/2014

 

        MFANAWENKHOSI MSELESELE NDLOVU

        V

REX

 

        (Attorney Zakhele Hlophe- Pro deo) (DPP’s Chambers   

        (Murder)

 

TUESDAY 24 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

57.    C OF A (CIV) 04/2016

       

         LIONEL OSWALD REID AND ANOTHER

         V

         MOSES MOTSA AND ANOTHER

 

         (Nkomondze Attorneys) (Nzima & Associates)

 

58.   C OF A (CRIM) 39/2014

 

        MKHAWULELI DLAMINI

        V

        REX

 

        (IN Person) (DPP’s Chambers)

        (Rape)

COURT B

 

59.   C OF A (CRIM) 26/2015

 

        MNCEDISI DASSA THOBILE

        V

        REX

 

       (Mabila Attorneys) (DPP’s Chambers)

       (Bail)

 

60.   C OF A (CIV) 21/2016

 

        ENLIGHTEN (PTY) LTD

        V

        HIL-SED DISTRIBUTORS (PTY) LTD AND 5 OTHERS

 

        (M.J Manzini & Associates) (N.E Ginindza Attorneys)

 

       

WEDNESDAY 25 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

61.    C OF A (CIV) 28/2016

   

         GORDON DONALD BREWS

         V

         GUY RICHARD MORE

 

         (Henwood & Company) (JM Currie Attorneys)

 

 

62.    C OF A (CIV) 39/2014

 

         DALLAS BUSANI DLAMINI & ANOTHER

         V

         COMMISSIONER OF POLICE & Another

 

         (Mabila Attorneys) (Attorney General’s Chambers)

COURT B

 

63.  C OF A (CIV) 64/2015

 

       MVUSELELO FAKUDZE

       V

       MILLICENT NOMALUNGELO FAKUDZE

 

       (Henwood & Company) (Magagula Attorneys)

 

 

 

64. C OF A (CIV) 8/2016

     

      SIMANGA GINA

      V

      CLEMENT SIMELANE

 

      (S.V Mdladla Attorneys) (Sithole Magagula Attorneys)

 

     

 

THURSDAY 26 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

 

65. C OF A (CIV) 20/2016

 

      SWAZILAND GOVERNMENT

      V

      MFANAZILE VUSI HLOPHE

 

      (Attorney General’s Chambers) (Mabila Attorneys)

 

 

 

 

 

 

66.  C OF A (CIV) 10/2016

 

       LUZALUZILE FARMERS ASSOCIATION LTD

       V

       THE REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES & 2 OTHERS

     

       (Mbuso Simelane & Associates) (Attorney General’s Chambers)

 

 

COURT B

 

67.  C OF A (CRIM) 21/2015

 

       SWAZI MDLULI & 2 OTHERS

       V

       REX

 

       (Attorney Sandile Motsa- Pro deo)   (DPP’s Chambers)

       (Murder)

 

 

68.   C OF A (CRIM) 4/2016

 

        DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS & 2 OTHERS

        V

        CELANI MAPONI NGUBANE

   

        (DPP’s Chambers)  (Bhembe Attorneys)

 

FRIDAY 27 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

69.   C OF A (CRIM) 31/2015

       

        DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

        V

        BHEKWAYO DLAMINI AND 2 OTHERS

 

        (DPP’S Chambers)  (T.R Maseko Attorneys)

 

70.   C OF A (CIV) 57/2015

                                                                                                                                                                      

         INTER AGENCIES (PTY) LTD

         V

         EUGENE DLAMINI

      

         (M.J. Manzini Associates) (Howe Masuku Nsibande Attorneys)

 

COURT B

 

71.   C OF A (CIV) 69/2015

 

        THEMBA NZUZA & 5 OTHERS

        V

        ENOCK MANDLA NZUZA

 

        (Mabila Attorneys) (CJ Littler & Company)

 

72.   C OF A (CIV) 73/2015

 

        SWAZILAND NATIONAL HOUSING BOARD

        V

        MARIA NTOMBI SIMELANE

 

        (Waring Attorneys) (Magagula Hlophe Attorneys)

 

 

MONDAY 30 MAY 2016

 

COURT A

 

73.    C OF A (CIV) 31/2016

 

         ENGEN PETROLEUM LTD AND ANOTHER

         V

         CUSTOM MOTORS PTY

 

         (Robinson Bertram Attorneys)  (Henwood & Company)

 

  

COURT B

 

74.    C OF A (CIV) 9/2016

 

         MUZI MABUZA AND 2 OTHERS

         V

         NATIONAL COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

 

        (Dlamini Kunene Associates) (Attorney General’s chambers)

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RESERVED FOR WRITING JUDGMENTS

31 MAY TO 16 JUNE 2016

 

 

 

 

DELIVERY OF JUDGMENTS

17 JUNE 2016 (09:00 a.m)                                                                                                                                 

           

 

 

 

                                         _____________________________________

                                        L. MSIMANGO                                                                                 REGISTRAR OF THE SUPREME COURT

 

                                      15th April 2016